Saturday’s Big MLB Favorites Create Over/Under Value

Jul 07, 2018 11:08 AM EDT

Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports. Pictured: Jose Altuve and George Springer

The Highlights:

  • Since the bottom of the ninth isn’t played when a home team is ahead, it would make sense that less runs should be scored in those games.
  • When the home team is a big favorite, it becomes increasingly likely that they’ll be ahead late in the game.
  • Saturday’s slate features two potential unders that could have value based on that theory.

Saturday’s MLB slate features a couple pretty, pretty big moneylines. The Nationals (-360) and Astros (-350) are the fourth and fifth biggest favorites on the season so far.

While there’s no question that a -300 home favorite is more likely to win the game, betting on such teams has not been a winning strategy for bettors (it’s actually been the underdog that has been profitable in these situations).

There is, however, a way to take advantage of their high win rate, and it comes by way of the total.


Since I am a baseball expert I know that when a home team is winning at the end of a game, the bottom of the ninth is not played. So as home teams are more heavily favored, it becomes increasingly likely that the game will see 17 half-innings instead of 18. On top of that, the lost half inning will always be taken away from the much stronger team — the one more likely to be scoring runs.

To test the theory, I put together a Bet Labs system with the following criteria:

  • Home team’s moneyline was -300 or higher
  • Closing total was 8 or less (low totals tend to attract more ‘over’ bettors)
  • Total did not rise from opening number (to filter out games with sharp action on the over)

The results: Unders have gone 42-18-1 for +22.26 units and a 36.5% ROI since 2005 (5-2 this season).

As long as both these totals stay put (or fall), I’ll be on both unders today.

How would you rate this article?
Follow Danny Donahue on Twitter

Top Stories