Best Colts-Chiefs Playoffs Prop Bets: Buckle in and Bet Patrick Mahomes

Best Colts-Chiefs Playoffs Prop Bets: Buckle in and Bet Patrick Mahomes article feature image

Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports. Pictured: Patrick Mahomes

  • There are two player props offering betting value in the early game on Saturday's NFL playoffs slate.
  • This piece will focus on Chiefs QB Patrick Mahomes and Chiefs RB Damien Williams.

The Chiefs and the Colts meet at Arrowhead for what is the highest-totaled game of NFL Division Weekend, and we’re checking in on two of best prop bets for the clash.

Kansas City enters the game as a 5-point favorite, hinting at a script which will have their offense dictating things from out in front. While that could mean big things for a chasing-the-game Andrew Luck, the Fantasy Labs Props Tool is leaning toward the unders on the Indianapolis gunslinger, so we’ll pivot to the other side of the ball.

And unfortunately for our collective blood pressure, than means going short on Patrick Mahomes and holding on for dear life.

Looking for more player prop bets? We’ve got in-depth prop coverage throughout the playoffs at Bet the Prop, and we also also post all of our latest picks on Twitter.

Chiefs QB Patrick Mahomes

Under 25.5 Completions

Mahomes averaged 23.9 completions in 2018, and in his first game of the new year, he hosts a defense allowing 24.3 completions per game.

Combine that with the fact that that Mahomes beat this number in just four of 16 appearances this year, I’m not sure why we’d be getting odds on the under.

The fact that the Chiefs’ defense is so much better at Arrowhead is working in our favor here — the unit gives up 16 fewer points per game at home than on the road (18 vs 34.6), somewhat reducing the need for any urgency on the part of the offense.

To be fair, that hasn’t mattered much as Andy Reid’s offense tends to keep its foot on the gas. Still, this line is too high — Since Week 5, Mahomes has gone under his completions total in nine of 12 games.

Even if the Colts buck expectations and turn this one into a shootout, the Chiefs’ propensity for big plays and short drives could still keep Mahomes’ passing volume down. Despite leading the league in scoring by a good margin, KC ranks just 28th in time of possession.

This bet has a rating of 7 in the Props Tool. The 25.5 number probably won’t move, but the price might, and I’d still play it to -115. 

Chiefs RB Damien Williams

Over 3.5 Receptions

This same line is currently paying as poorly as -150 at other books, so grab this value if you can.

Williams had just one catch in a 35-3 beat down of the Raiders in Week 17, but in the three games leading up that, he caught 17 of the 18 targets sent his way for a 94% catch rate and a 5.7 reception average.

During that span, Williams ranked behind only Christian McCaffrey and Ezekiel Elliott in running back receptions.

While the Colts give up the ninth-fewest rushing yards per game, only two teams have given up more receptions to opposing running backs, making that an obvious area for the Chiefs to attack.

  • Including Lamar Miller’s eight-catch outing in the wildcard game, the Colts have given up at least four receptions to an RB in six of their last seven.
  • On the season, they allow on average of 6.9 RB catches per game.

This price is almost certain to move and align with the higher juice currently being offered at other books. I’d still pay up to about -135 to make this wager.