Cavaliers vs. Pacers Odds & Betting Predictions - May 12, 2025

Cavaliers at Pacers

12:00 am • TNT

Cleveland Cavaliers

1-4

109

109 - 129

Indiana Pacers

4-1

129

MatchupOpenSpreadTotalMoneyline
Cavaliers 1-4	-4.5	-5-112	o230.5-112	-225
Pacers 4-1	u230.5	+5-108	u230.5-110	+185

Monday 12:00 a.m.

May 12, 2025

Gainbridge FieldhouseIndianapolis

CLE o100.5 Team Total (Live)-108

1.02u

Over 115.5 (2H)-115

CLE -113 (Live)

1.13u

Under 230.5-106

1.06u

CLE -5-112

1.02u

CLE -5-110

2.2u

CLE -5.5-108

O.Toppin o7.5 Pts-110

B.Mathurin o12.5 Pts-110

1.1u

D.Mitchell o5.5 Ast+110

Over 113 (1H)-105

D.Mitchell o10.5 Rebs+Ast-115

CLE -5.5-108

Hitting at 62% ATS🔥🔥🔥 LIKE = TAILING❤️

M.Turner o15.5 Pts-105

0.95u

T.Haliburton u17.5 Pts-110

M.Strus o10.5 Pts-120

T.Jerome u8.5 Pts-108

M.Strus o2.5 3pt M-115

T.Haliburton u2.5 3pt M-160

E.Mobley o28.5 Pts+Rebs-110

0.27u

B.Mathurin o13.5 Pts+110

0.25u

A.Nesmith o12.5 Pts-115

0.29u

E.Mobley u21.5 Pts+Ast-125

0.96u

D.Mitchell o30.5 Pts-104

0.27u

D.Mitchell o30.5 Pts-102

1.02u

IND +5.5-110

D.Garland o14.5 Pts-128

M.Turner o15.5 Pts-108

0.25u

D.Mitchell o35.5 Pts+Ast-108

0.6u

IND +5.5-108

2.78u

A.Nesmith o4.5 Rebs-130

T.Jerome o9.5 Pts+102

1.1u

D.Mitchell o29.5 Pts-125

Just going to keep rocking with Mitchell here as he’s been scorching hot this series and honestly this entire season against Indiana. Mitchell has exceeded this line in every game this series with 33, 48, and 43 points just getting to the rack with ease while generating and even finishing through contact. The craziest part of this entire thing has been he has not even been all that efficient from 3 point range yet. Darius Garland returned in Game 3 but only managed 25 minutes with his injury. While slightly limited minutes may give Mitchell a bit of a boost, Mitchell plays very well off of Garland and gets a few extra catch and shoot 3 opportunities when they play together. Indiana simply has no answer for Mitchell as he has put this team on his back.

Haliburton u6.5 3PA-115

0.87u

Something’s not right with Hali, wrist bugging him maybe and Cavs just not giving him any space and forcing others to beat them. He’s down to 1.5 3PA the last two games after 7.8 the rest of the playoffs and just 4.5 ast on 10.5 potentials way down from 19 pot in G1.

T.Haliburton u9.5 Ast-110

0.91u

T.Jerome u5.5 Pts+350

0.25u

Just 2 pts each of the last two games, can’t make a 2 to save his life, down to just 13’ last game as he struggles. Still in their interest to get him going again and this is super low so just a nibble in case he stays ice cold.

IND +175

0.51u

Cavaliers vs Pacers Game 4: Moore's 5 Best Bets for Tonight
Matt Moore•
May 11, 2025 UTC
Thunder vs Nuggets: 3 Player Props for Sunday Afternoon
Michael Arinze•
May 11, 2025 UTC
Thunder vs Nuggets: +255 Parlay for Sunday Afternoon
Dead President Picks•
May 11, 2025 UTC
2 NBA Best Bets for Cavaliers-Pacers Tonight
Action Network Staff•
May 11, 2025 UTC

See more NBA Coverage

No props found

NBA Public Betting

Pacers are 4-1 in their last 5 games.
Pacers are 2-3 in their last 5 games against the spread
Pacers are 19-22 in their road games against the spread
The totals have gone OVER in 3 of Pacers' last 5 games
The totals have gone OVER in 21 of Pacers' 41 last games at home

Against the Spread (ATS) History

	overall	home	away	favorite	underdog
Pacers	36-44-2	17-22-2	19-22	20-28-2	16-14
Cavaliers	48-33-1	22-18-1	26-15	42-31-1	6-2

Over/Under History

	overall	home o/u	away o/u	favorite o/u	underdog o/u
Pacers	45-37	21-20	24-17	23-27	21-9
Cavaliers	50-31-1	25-16	25-15-1	46-27-1	4-4

Straight-Up (ML) History

	overall	home	away	favorite	underdog
Pacers	8-2	N/A	N/A	35-15	15-15
Cavaliers	5-4	N/A	N/A	60-14	4-4

date	opponent	score	spread	over/under	moneyline
May 9th	CLE	L 104-126	+5.5 L	U 232	CLE +180
May 6th	@CLE	W 120-119	+5.5 W	O 227	IND +190
May 4th	@CLE	W 121-112	+8.5 W	O 229	IND +280
Apr 29th	MIL	W 119-118	-8 L	O 222	IND -360
Apr 28th	@MIL	W 129-103	+4 W	O 226.5	IND +154