College Football Rankings for Week 5: Brett McMurphy’s AP Top 25 Poll Ballot vs. Our Betting Power Ratings

College Football Rankings for Week 5: Brett McMurphy’s AP Top 25 Poll Ballot vs. Our Betting Power Ratings article feature image
Credit:

Matthew Holst/Getty Images. Pictured: The Iowa Hawkeyes.

I recently streamed a 2011 football film starring Kurt Russell titled “Touchback.” It was one of the worst movies I’ve ever seen. Please watch it.

One of my favorite lines in a list of few was when the main character, a high school football player, is discussing his college recruitment in the locker room with a friend, who quips, “Don’t go to Hawaii, man! That school sucks.”

And at that moment of time I knew whoever had their fingerprints on this script knew absolutely nothing about college football.

It doesn’t matter if you bet over, ‘dog, chalk or under at 11:59 on Saturdays, when Hawaii and their opponents take the field on Facebook Live — everyone loves Hawaii. Be more wrong, producers. Embarrassing. I spent the majority of the weekend thinking of a less hateable team, and I couldn’t.

Also, if you think Hawaii sucks, I’ve got news for you, kid: Welcome to Week 5 of the 2021 season. Just about every team sucks.

To get us rolling into the new week, we have Brett McMurphy’s AP Top 25 poll and Collin Wilson’s Power Ratings to compare and contrast.

Here’s how the two experts have shuffled their pecking order following a whacky Week 4.

The ultimate CFB betting cheat code

Best bets for every game

Collin Wilson’s biggest weekly edges

Profitable data-driven system picks

Brett McMurphy’s AP Top 25 Ballot Entering Week 5

AP denotes Brett McMurphy’s Associated Press Top 25 ballot.
PR denotes Collin Wilson’s College Football Betting Power Ratings.


1

AP

Alabama

1

PR

2

AP

Georgia

2

PR

3

AP

Oregon

14

PR

4

AP

Penn State

5

PR

5

AP

Arkansas

17

PR

Is Woo Pig Sooie the most likable team in the country for those without a rooting interest? Tough to argue at this point.

McMurphy’s buying the juice, slotting the Razorbacks into the top 5. Wilson, meanwhile, is just one week closer to finding hotel reservations near Lucas Oil Stadium in late January, with no choice other than to push the Razorbacks up to No. 17 — six spots up from last week’s ranking.

Head coach Sam Pittman is a genius. Quarterback K.J. Jefferson doesn’t throw the ball unless it’s a deep vertical. Offensive coordinator Kendal Briles is whipping up pristine game plans. The defense is top-10 nationally in points allowed (14.5).

Big two weeks coming up for the squad, with games against Georgia and Ole Miss on deck.

Updated 2021 College Football Betting Power Ratings

6

AP

Iowa

13

PR

If you have to start by saying “This team might not be flashy, but they get the job done!” when profiling a contender, it’s not ideal.

The playoff is reserved for bombshells. Iowa has … a terrific personality.

Spencer Petras, who would suddenly melt into a puddle of mush if the quick-out route or tight end seam were prohibited from college football, is your quarterback. Half the tape he sends NFL scouts will be handoffs to Tyler Goodson.

The defense, which is apt to score more points than the offense on a weekly basis, has yet to play a team that can complete a forward pass.

Plus, I’m firmly convinced Kirk Ferentz would need a minute to decide between cracking the Playoff, or drawing some faltering Pac-12 squad in the Music City Bowl l if given the choice.

Nobody likes steamrolling an opponent in a meaningless postseason game as a 3-point favorite more than Iowa.


7

AP

Notre Dame

19

PR

8

AP

Cincinnati

7

PR

9

AP

Florida

6

PR

10

AP

Ohio State

3

PR

11

AP

BYU

52

PR

12

AP

Ole Miss

11

PR

13

AP

Michigan

18

PR

14

AP

Fresno State

58

PR

There’s a huge disagreement on Fresno State, which has been one of the most volatile clubs in the nation.

A team that blew out UConn and picked up an upset win over UCLA on the road nearly lost to UNLV as 30.5-point underdogs last Friday, but unlike Minnesota, got it together down the stretch to remain undefeated.

BYU and Cincinnati are the two non-Power Five clubs ahead of Fresno in McMurphy’s rankings, while Wilson’s showing love for Coastal, SMU, Boise State, Marshall and Nevada.

Don’t sleep on a fun race in the Group of Five.


15

AP

Oklahoma

4

PR

16

AP

NC State

29

PR

17

AP

Texas A&M

9

PR

18

AP

Michigan State

36

PR

19

AP

Baylor

47

PR

20

AP

UCLA

20

PR

21

AP

San Diego State

80

PR

22

AP

Coastal Carolina

31

PR

23

AP

SMU

56

PR

24

AP

Oklahoma State

37

PR

25

AP

Wake Forest

34

PR

NR

AP

Clemson

15

PR

Clemson went from playoff hopeful to likely laying 11 points over a Mountain West team in the Cricket by Wireless Bojangles Bowl in the drop of a hat. They’re not even ranked in McMurphy’s poll and sit 15th in Wilson’s power ratings.

Through three games against FBS teams in 2021, the Tigers are averaging 12.7 points per game. That’s worse than both Akron and Bowling Green, which are a combined 7-36 under their active head coaches.

McMurphy’s already dismissed Dabo from his list, while Collin’s likely one more dud away from joining.

Perhaps the most amusing part of the Clemson slump is simultaneously watching Miami and North Carolina choke. Of all the years the Tigers gift away the ACC, nobody wants anything to do with it.

Find me in the fetal position when Dave Clawson and 8-4 Wake Forest win the conference.

The must-have app for college football bettors

The best NCAAF betting scoreboard

Free picks from proven pros

Live win probabilities for your bets

How would you rate this article?