MLB Betting Rules for Shortened Games: When Bets Do — and Don’t — Get Refunded
- Many bets were impacted Monday by the decision to call the Indians-Pirates game after six innings.
- Despite officially winning 7-0, Pirates +1.5 (+125) was graded as no action. Same goes for those who bet the Pirates' team total over 3.5 runs.
- The official rules at most shops: Moneyline bets are official once the game goes five innings, but wagers on the over/under, team totals and/or runline get refunded if the game doesn't go the full nine innings.
Imagine sitting down on Monday and deciding to bet on the Pirates runline (+1.5 runs) at +125. You saw too much value on a Pittsburgh team that had won nine straight games.
And you weren’t afraid to take on Cleveland’s Corey Kluber, as the two-time Cy Young winner hasn’t looked like himself lately. So you locked in your bet and were feeling good.
After a short rain delay, neither team scored in the first inning, but then Josh Harrison hit a two-strike, two-out homer to give Pittsburgh a 3-0 lead.
The Pirates added another run in the second to go up 4-0. You could almost smell the money that +1.5 ticket would bring home. That score held until a second rain delay in the third inning.
Now, you started to worry.
Two primary wagering rules apply when baseball games get called early:
- Full-game moneylines become official once the game goes five innings — or if the home team leads after 4.5 innings.
- In contrast, wagers on the over/under, team totals and/or runlines don’t become official until the teams complete nine innings — or the home team leads after 8.5 innings.
(Note: These should apply at most legitimate shops, but always check the rules of your specific book.)
When play resumed at “The Jake,” you still held out hope none of this would apply.
The Pirates picked up right where they left off, tagging Kluber for three more runs in the top of the fourth to go up a touchdown. It suddenly turned into a Steelers-Browns game.
The Pirates maintained that margin into the sixth inning, then things got mildly dicey when the Tribe loaded the bases with only one out. However, starter Trevor Williams wiggled out of the jam without any damage.
Holding a +1.5 ticket with a seven-run lead through six innings is as good as it gets.
But then a THIRD rain delay! It suddenly hit you that they might call the game after a third delay in the seventh inning of a blowout. You knew neither team would protest much.
So you waited …
And waited some more, while frantically monitoring radars, MLB Network and social media.
>> Sign up for The Action Network’s daily newsletter to get the smartest conversation delivered into your inbox each morning.
You eventually saw the game was called, meaning you wouldn’t cash your Pirates +1.5 (+125) ticket — despite officially winning the game 7-0! Instead, you simply got your money back.
Over 8.5 bettors also weren’t pleased, as they also settled for a refund. While you can’t assume a game will go over, it likely would’ve cashed. At least the over didn’t already hit, which would’ve been even worse. I previously wrote about fixing that exact scenario, which has happened before.
Unless you bet the first-five innings or either moneyline, you had your bet refunded — even if you bet Pirates team total over 3.5, the worst beat of them all.
On the flip side, those who bet the Indians -1.5, Pirates team total under 3.5 or even the under 8.5 couldn’t be happier, as the (likely) losing wagers got refunded.
(If you had all three of those, go buy a lottery ticket tomorrow.)