Yankees vs Rays Prediction | Best MLB Player Props & Home Run Predictions Today for NYY vs TB (Game 2)

Our Yankees vs Rays prediction for Game 2 of this ALDS rematch rounds up the best MLB player props today, plus the best home run bets today, straight from the live Polymarket board for NYY vs TB.

• The Yankees arrive 0-1 after dropping the series opener, but they're a 1.89x moneyline price tonight behind ace Cam Schlittler, and Aaron Judge working his way back into the lineup only adds to the firepower.
• The Rays sit 1-0 and get the home-field edge at Tropicana Field, leaning on Junior Caminero's thunder in the middle of the order behind Freddy Peralta's 10-11, 4.42 ERA ledger on the mound.

Here is our full NYY vs TB picks table before we break down every home run prediction, prop bet, and the full moneyline board for tonight's Game 2.

Best MLB Player Props & HR Bets for Yankees vs Rays Game 2

Every pick below is a real trade we'd make after redeeming the Polymarket promo code (ACTION), part of our best MLB player props today for this entire Game 2 matchup, ranked from the safest number down to the long shots.

Use Polymarket promo code ACTION and Deposit $10, Get a $25 Trading Bonus!

Best Hits + Runs + RBIs Prop Today – Jazz Chisholm Jr. 1+

Jazz Chisholm Jr. gives the Yankees a dynamic, multi-tool presence at the top of the lineup, and a combo prop like this one is built to hit almost any night he's in the box score.

He doesn't need a hit, a run, and an RBI all at once, just one of the three, and a Yankees club averaging nine runs a game this postseason gives him plenty of ways to clear this number.

At a $100 buy near 60 cents, this trade works out to roughly 167 shares, with Polymarket's stated payout at $162.50.

• If Chisholm records a hit, run, or RBI: profit of $162.50.
• If he does none of the three: the $100 stake is a total loss.

It's priced like a near coin flip plus a bit of a cushion, and it still returns better than 1.6x your stake in pure profit.

Best Strikeouts Prop Today – Freddy Peralta 5+

Freddy Peralta carries a 10-11 record and a 4.42 ERA into tonight's start, but strikeouts have never been his problem, he's already punched out 156 hitters this season.

Getting the ball at home against a Yankees lineup that chases secondary stuff gives him a real path to clearing five strikeouts well before his night is done.

At 58 cents, a $100 buy works out to roughly 172 shares, with the stated payout at $167.51.

• If Peralta strikes out five or more: profit of $167.51.
• If he doesn't: the $100 stake is a total loss.

A near coin-flip number for a swing-and-miss arm, and it still pays out nearly 1.7x your stake.

Best Strikeouts Prop Today – Cam Schlittler 7+

Cam Schlittler takes a 14-6 record and a sparkling 1.95 ERA into Game 2, and his 239 strikeouts this season put him near the top of the league in swing-and-miss stuff.

Tampa Bay's lineup carries real swing-and-miss risk of its own, and Schlittler has eclipsed seven strikeouts regularly all year long.

At 53 cents, $100 buys roughly 189 shares, with a stated payout of $182.71.

• If Schlittler strikes out seven or more: profit of $182.71.
• If he doesn't: the $100 stake is a total loss.

Another near coin-flip price that still returns nearly 1.8x your stake in pure profit.

Best Total Bases Prop Today – Cody Bellinger 2+

Cody Bellinger has been one of the hottest bats on the roster entering this series, capping the Wild Card clincher over Boston with a three-run homer.

Two total bases is a low bar for a hitter running this hot, and Peralta's 4.42 ERA gives Bellinger a real chance to do damage early.

At 40 cents, a $100 buy works out to roughly 250 shares, with the stated payout at $240.00.

• If Bellinger clears two total bases: profit of $240.00.
• If he doesn't: the $100 stake is a total loss.

A shorter price than most of this board, but it still more than doubles your stake in pure profit.

Best Total Bases Prop Today – Jonathan Aranda 2+

Jonathan Aranda has quietly been one of Tampa Bay's steadiest contact hitters, and the kind of gap-to-gap approach that routinely turns into extra-base knocks.

Schlittler misses plenty of bats, but he's also prone to the occasional well-struck ball when hitters put the barrel on it, and Aranda profiles as exactly that type of hitter.

At 30 cents, $100 buys roughly 333 shares, with a stated payout of $317.86.

• If Aranda clears two total bases: profit of $317.86.
• If he doesn't: the $100 stake is a total loss.

A longer shot than Bellinger's number, but the payout here clears better than 3-to-1.

Best RBIs Prop Today – Yandy Díaz 1+

Yandy Díaz rarely strikes out and puts the ball in play as consistently as anyone in Tampa Bay's lineup, which keeps him in the mix for an RBI chance even when he's not the one hitting for power.

With Caminero and García Jr. hitting around him, Díaz figures to see plenty of runners on base to drive in tonight.

At 25 cents, $100 buys roughly 400 shares, with a stated payout of $380.20.

• If Díaz drives in a run: profit of $380.20.
• If he doesn't: the $100 stake is a total loss.

A real longshot number, but the payout here is nearly 3.8-to-1.

Best Home Run Prop Today – Ben Rice 1+

Ben Rice has carried a bigger share of the Yankees' middle-of-the-order power while Aaron Judge worked his way back from injury, and that role doesn't disappear the moment Judge returns to the lineup.

A left-handed bat with real pull-side pop, Rice profiles as a live threat against a Rays staff still searching for length behind Peralta.

At 21 cents, $100 buys roughly 476 shares, with a stated payout of $451.42.

• If Rice goes deep: profit of $451.42.
• If he doesn't: the $100 stake is a total loss.

A true home run predictions today longshot, but the payout here clears better than 4.5-to-1.

Best Home Run Prop Today – Junior Caminero 1+

Junior Caminero is the engine of this Rays lineup after a 42-homer, 101-RBI regular season, and he's exactly the kind of bat capable of erasing a Game 1 deficit with one swing.

Schlittler misses bats at an elite clip, but even the best strikeout arms leave mistakes over the plate, and Caminero punishes mistakes as well as anyone in the league.

At 20 cents, $100 buys roughly 500 shares, with a stated payout of $473.65.

• If Caminero homers: profit of $473.65.
• If he doesn't: the $100 stake is a total loss.

Another real longshot on tonight's home run predictions today board, paying out nearly 4.75-to-1.

Best Home Run Prop Today – Luis García Jr. 1+

Luis García Jr. has emerged as a legitimate power threat in Tampa Bay's lineup, and his bat speed gives him real equity even lower in the order.

He won't see the same pitch selection as Caminero, but that can work in his favor against a Yankees staff more focused on the bigger name hitting behind him.

At 16 cents, $100 buys roughly 625 shares, with a stated payout of $590.50.

• If García homers: profit of $590.50.
• If he doesn't: the $100 stake is a total loss.

A deep longshot, but the payout here is nearly 6-to-1.

Best Home Run Prop Today – Yandy Díaz 1+

Yandy Díaz has built his career on contact over power, which is exactly why this price sits at the bottom of tonight's home run predictions today board.

He's not the profile to chase for a home run most nights, but a mistake pitch from Schlittler can leave the yard off anyone in this lineup, Díaz included.

At 10 cents, $100 buys 1,000 shares, with a stated payout of $941.10.

• If Díaz homers: profit of $941.10.
• If he doesn't: the $100 stake is a total loss.

The deepest longshot on the board tonight, but the payout here is more than 9-to-1.

NYY vs TB Moneyline, Spread & Total

Before the board dives into player props, here's where this Yankees vs Rays prediction stands on the base game lines for Game 2.

Home Run Predictions Today for NYY vs TB

Our home run predictions today cover every hitter Polymarket has priced on this board, sorted from the safest bet down to the deepest longshot.

• Ben Rice (Home Run 1+: Yes 21%): carrying a bigger share of the Yankees' power while Judge worked back from injury.
• Junior Caminero (Home Run 1+: Yes 20%): the 42-homer engine of Tampa Bay's lineup.
• Spencer Jones (NYY) (Home Run 1+: Yes 18%): a power-over-hit prospect bat who can change a game with one swing.
• Luis García Jr. (Home Run 1+: Yes 16%): real bat speed and pop lower in the order.
• Cody Bellinger (Home Run 1+: Yes 15%): the hottest bat in the Yankees lineup right now.
• Jazz Chisholm Jr. (Home Run 1+: Yes 13%): explosive bat speed that can clear the fence from either side of the diamond's power alleys.
• Victor Mesa Jr. (TB) (Home Run 1+: Yes 12%): a speed-first profile with occasional pop mixed in.
• Jonathan Aranda (Home Run 1+: Yes 12%): a steady gap-to-gap approach for Tampa Bay that occasionally turns into a homer.
• Yandy Díaz (Home Run 1+: Yes 10%): a contact-over-power profile that still has mistake-pitch equity.
• Richie Palacios (TB) (Home Run 1+: Yes 8%): a table-setter type without a ton of over-the-fence pop.
• Liam Hicks (TB) (Home Run 1+: Yes 7%): a depth catching bat with modest raw power.
• Jonny DeLuca (TB) (Home Run 1+: Yes 7%): a complementary outfield bat further down the lineup.
• Taylor Walls (TB) (Home Run 1+: Yes 5%): a glove-first infielder with the longest price on the board.

Hits Props

• Chandler Simpson (TB) (Hits 1+: Yes 67%): a top-of-the-order speedster who puts the ball in play constantly.
• Yandy Díaz (Hits 1+: Yes 66%): one of the toughest outs in Tampa Bay's lineup.
• Luis García Jr. (Hits 1+: Yes 65%): consistent barrel contact to go with his raw pop.
• Cody Bellinger (Hits 1+: Yes 64%): locked in at the plate entering Game 2.
• Ben Rice (Hits 1+: Yes 62%): a patient approach that still finds the barrel often enough.
• Junior Caminero (Hits 1+: Yes 61%): elite bat-to-ball skills to go with his power.
• Liam Hicks (Hits 1+: Yes 58%): a solid contact bat for a depth catcher.
• Spencer Jones (Hits 1+: Yes 57%): swing-and-miss risk, but enough raw ability to still get a knock.
• Jonny DeLuca (Hits 1+: Yes 55%): a fringe everyday bat who still makes enough contact.
• Victor Mesa Jr. (Hits 1+: Yes 54%): a speed-driven profile that only needs to slap one through the infield.
• Jazz Chisholm Jr. (Hits 1+: Yes 54%): an aggressive approach that can work against him on a tougher night.
• Jonathan Aranda (Hits 1+: Yes 54%): steady enough to clear this number on most nights.
• Richie Palacios (Hits 1+: Yes 48%): a lower-average bat near the bottom of the order.
• Taylor Walls (Hits 1+: Yes 47%): the toughest number on this board given his light bat.

Total Bases Props

• Luis García Jr. (Total Bases 2+: Yes 41%): real pop that turns singles into extra-base knocks.
• Ben Rice (Total Bases 2+: Yes 40%): pull-side power that clears this number easily on contact.
• Cody Bellinger (Total Bases 2+: Yes 40%): the hottest bat in the Yankees lineup right now.
• Junior Caminero (Total Bases 2+: Yes 39%): the engine of Tampa Bay's lineup.
• Yandy Díaz (Total Bases 2+: Yes 36%): enough gap power to clear this number without needing a homer.
• Chandler Simpson (Total Bases 2+: Yes 33%): speed that can stretch a single into extra bases.
• Spencer Jones (Total Bases 2+: Yes 31%): a boom-or-bust power bat.
• Victor Mesa Jr. (Total Bases 2+: Yes 30%): needs to leg out extra bases rather than hit for power.
• Jazz Chisholm Jr. (Total Bases 2+: Yes 30%): explosive bat speed with real extra-base upside on contact.
• Jonathan Aranda (Total Bases 2+: Yes 30%): a gap-to-gap hitter who can still produce two bases.
• Liam Hicks (Total Bases 2+: Yes 27%): modest raw power for a depth catcher.
• Jonny DeLuca (Total Bases 2+: Yes 26%): a complementary bat further down the order.
• Richie Palacios (Total Bases 2+: Yes 23%): a table-setter without much over-the-fence pop.
• Taylor Walls (Total Bases 2+: Yes 23%): a glove-first infielder with the lightest bat on this board.

Hits + Runs + RBIs Combo Props

• Jonathan Aranda (Hits + Runs + RBIs 1+: Yes 63%): steady enough to produce in at least one of these three columns most nights.
• Liam Hicks (Hits + Runs + RBIs 1+: Yes 61%): a contact bat with multiple paths to cash this prop.
• Jonny DeLuca (Hits + Runs + RBIs 1+: Yes 61%): a low bar for a bat that just needs to reach base or score.
• Victor Mesa Jr. (Hits + Runs + RBIs 1+: Yes 60%): his speed alone creates extra run-scoring chances.
• Jazz Chisholm Jr. (Hits + Runs + RBIs 1+: Yes 59%): a dynamic, multi-tool presence that fills the box score in several ways.
• Taylor Walls (Hits + Runs + RBIs 1+: Yes 56%): a low bar even for a lighter bat in the lineup.
• Richie Palacios (Hits + Runs + RBIs 1+: Yes 53%): a table-setter who just needs to reach base once.
• Cody Bellinger (Hits + Runs + RBIs 2+: Yes 48%): the hottest bat in the Yankees lineup, priced for a tougher two-category clip.
• Ben Rice (Hits + Runs + RBIs 2+: Yes 48%): real power that can fill multiple categories on one swing.
• Junior Caminero (Hits + Runs + RBIs 2+: Yes 47%): the engine of Tampa Bay's lineup, priced at the tougher two-category number.
• Luis García Jr. (Hits + Runs + RBIs 2+: Yes 47%): pop and contact that gives him multiple ways to clear this number.
• Yandy Díaz (Hits + Runs + RBIs 2+: Yes 45%): one of the toughest outs in Tampa Bay's lineup, even at the harder threshold.
• Chandler Simpson (Hits + Runs + RBIs 2+: Yes 44%): a top-of-the-order speedster with real run-scoring equity.
• Spencer Jones (Hits + Runs + RBIs 2+: Yes 43%): a boom-or-bust bat priced for the tougher two-category clip.

RBI Props

• Victor Mesa Jr. (RBIs 1+: Yes 34%): speed on the bases that can still turn into a run driven in.
• Spencer Jones (RBIs 1+: Yes 33%): enough raw power to drive in a run on one swing.
• Luis García Jr. (RBIs 1+: Yes 32%): real bat speed and pop lower in the order.
• Junior Caminero (RBIs 1+: Yes 31%): the clear run-producer in Tampa Bay's lineup.
• Ben Rice (RBIs 1+: Yes 31%): carrying a bigger share of the Yankees' power this series.
• Cody Bellinger (RBIs 1+: Yes 26%): the hottest bat in the Yankees lineup, with plenty of chances to drive in a run.
• Yandy Díaz (RBIs 1+: Yes 25%): hitting in the middle of a Rays lineup that should put runners on base.
• Jonny DeLuca (RBIs 1+: Yes 25%): a complementary bat who can still cash in with a timely knock.
• Liam Hicks (RBIs 1+: Yes 25%): a contact bat capable of a two-out knock.
• Jazz Chisholm Jr. (RBIs 1+: Yes 24%): explosive bat speed that can drive in a run in a hurry.
• Richie Palacios (RBIs 1+: Yes 23%): a table-setter who projects for fewer RBI chances.
• Jonathan Aranda (RBIs 1+: Yes 22%): a steady gap-to-gap hitter without a ton of run-producing pop.
• Chandler Simpson (RBIs 1+: Yes 20%): a leadoff profile built for runs scored more than runs driven in.

Pitcher Strikeout Props

Our pitcher strikeout props cover the full threshold ladder Polymarket has priced for both Game 2 starters.

• Cam Schlittler (Strikeouts 6+: Yes 69%): a near-lock number given his 239-strikeout season.
• Freddy Peralta (Strikeouts 5+: Yes 58%): swing-and-miss stuff even in a rockier overall season.
• Cam Schlittler (Strikeouts 7+: Yes 53%): a 1.95 ERA arm that misses bats deep into most starts.
• Freddy Peralta (Strikeouts 6+: Yes 39%): a tougher number, but his strikeout stuff travels well at home.
• Cam Schlittler (Strikeouts 8+: Yes 37%): a ceiling number for an arm who's gone deep into games all year.
• Cam Schlittler (Strikeouts 9+: Yes 25%): a real longshot that still has legs given his per-start strikeout rate.
• Freddy Peralta (Strikeouts 7+: Yes 24%): would require one of his better swing-and-miss nights of the season.
• Cam Schlittler (Strikeouts 10+: Yes 15%): the deepest longshot on his side of the ladder.
• Freddy Peralta (Strikeouts 8+: Yes 13%): a true ceiling outcome given his 4.42 ERA season.
• Freddy Peralta (Strikeouts 9+: Yes 7%): the longest price on the entire strikeout board tonight.

What's Moving the Market

Prediction markets and prices can move for several reasons. Tonight's board leans on the Yankees' pitching edge with Cam Schlittler on the mound, even though New York is the team playing from behind 0-1 in this series.

That gap between Schlittler's 1.95 ERA and Peralta's 4.42 ERA is exactly why our best MLB player props today skew toward Yankees hitters across the moneyline, spread, and total bases props.

Tampa Bay's homefield edge at Tropicana Field keeps the Rays moneyline price short despite the pitching matchup, and Junior Caminero's power anchors Tampa Bay's half of tonight's home run predictions today board.

Aaron Judge working back into the lineup is also worth tracking, since any added thump in the middle of New York's order could shift these MLB player props before first pitch.

That mix of a shorter-priced moneyline favorite and a wide-open power board is what makes tonight's game some of the best home run bets today across the entire NYY vs TB series.

How to Trade These MLB Player Props on Polymarket

Ready to get in on these MLB player props yourself? Here's exactly how to claim the bonus and start trading tonight's board:

• Read a comprehensive Polymarket review to understand how this exchange operates.
• Follow this guide to trading on Polymarket to learn how to buy your first "Yes" or "No" contract.
• Monitor the relevant tab on Polymarket to stay ahead of the live order book movements.
• When you're ready, sign up with Polymarket promo code ACTION to get started!

📝 POLYMARKET TERMS & CONDITIONS

18+ Only. Restrictions and eligibility requirements apply. Not available in all jurisdictions. Trading is risky. 100% loss can occur. See polymarket.com/tos for more information. The Polymarket US App serves as an independent software provider and affiliate of Polymarket US and Polymarket Clearing, the CFTC-regulated exchange and clearing organization.

Final Thoughts: Yankees vs Rays Prediction

Game 2 sets up as a pitching-driven night, with Cam Schlittler's dominant season going up against a Rays lineup still carrying the series lead into Tropicana Field.

Our best MLB player props today lean on Schlittler's strikeout upside and New York's hitters finding extra bases, while Tampa Bay's power bats still offer real home run predictions today value further down the board.

For NYY vs TB specifically, the best home run bets today still run through Tampa Bay's middle of the order, even with the Yankees favored on the moneyline tonight.

That wraps our full Yankees vs Rays prediction and every best MLB player props today pick we'd make on the Polymarket board for Game 2.

Yankees vs Rays Prediction FAQs

Who wins the Yankees vs Rays prediction for Game 2?

The Polymarket board favors the Yankees at 53% to win outright on the moneyline, even though New York enters the game down 0-1 in the series.

What are the best MLB player props for this game?

Our top plays lean on Cam Schlittler's strikeout total, Cody Bellinger's total bases floor, and the home run board topped by Ben Rice and Junior Caminero.

What are the best home run predictions today for Yankees vs Rays?

Ben Rice and Junior Caminero sit atop tonight's home run board, with Luis García Jr. and Yandy Díaz priced as the deeper longshots.

How do I use promo code on Polymarket?

Create an account, make a qualifying deposit, and enter the promo code shown above to unlock a trading bonus before first pitch.

What time does Yankees vs Rays Game 2 start?

Game 2 is scheduled for 8:00 PM EDT at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg, Florida.

Who are the probable pitchers for Game 2?

Cam Schlittler takes the mound for the Yankees, and Freddy Peralta starts for the Rays.

What are the best home run bets today for NYY vs TB?

Ben Rice and Junior Caminero carry the shortest prices on tonight's board, while Luis García Jr. and Yandy Díaz offer the deepest home run bets today for anyone chasing a bigger multiple.