Rays vs. Yankees Odds & Betting Predictions - September 23, 2026

Rays at Yankees

11:05 pm • RAYS
2 - 9
Starting Pitchers
pitcherteameraw-l
Gerrit Cole logoG.ColeNew York Yankees logo3.6110-9
Mason Englert logoM.EnglertTampa Bay Rays logo5.950-4

Rays at Yankees Odds

Spread, Total, Moneyline

MatchupOpenSpreadTotalMoneyline
Rays
8-6
+1.5
+1.5-200
o6.5-112
+121
Yankees
2-3
u7.5
-1.5+164
u6.5-107
-143
location pinWednesday 11:05 p.m.
September 23, 2026
Yankee StadiumBronx
Rays vs. Yankees Expert Picks
YBK Picks.com
Last 30d: 45-39-4 (+11.2u)
TB +115
2u
I.Seymour u3.5 Hits Allowed+130
0.38u
TB +120
0.42u
Brian Bitler
Brian Bitler
Last 30d: 74-86-1 (-34.5u)
Under 6.5-102
3u
Topper
Topper
Last 30d: 115-105-2 (-22.7u)
TB +122
1u
Late Season Division Dogs Overall: 244-196-0,55% (ROI:28%) Season:3-10-0,23% (ROI:-53%) #TSA
Under 6.5-104
1u
Low Lid Lock (***) Overall: 572-429-48,57% (ROI:10%) Season:29-33-2,47% (ROI:-11%) #TSA

Rays vs. Yankees Previews & Analysis

  • DiSturco's Prop for Rays vs Yankees article feature image

    DiSturco's Prop for Rays vs Yankees

    Charlie Disturco•
    Sep 23, 2026 UTC
  • DiSturco: 3 HR Props to Trade on Kalshi Today article feature image

    DiSturco: 3 HR Props to Trade on Kalshi Today

    Charlie Disturco•
    Sep 23, 2026 UTC
See more MLB Coverage Right Arrow

Prop Odds Comparison

Right Arrow
Right Arrow

Loading props…

Line Movement Tracker

Right Arrow
Right Arrow

Rays vs. Yankees Public Betting Percentages

Away Logo

Rays

Public

29%

Bets%

71%

Money%

Matchup History

Against the Spread (ATS) History

overallhomeawayfavoriteunderdog
Yankees
81-8041-3940-4164-6617-14
Rays
84-7841-4043-3853-5330-25

Over/Under History

overallhome o/uaway o/ufavorite o/uunderdog o/u
Yankees
76-80-542-36-234-44-358-68-418-12-1
Rays
75-84-336-43-239-41-151-52-324-31

Straight-Up (ML) History

overallhomeawayfavoriteunderdog
Yankees
93-6846-3447-3477-5316-15
Rays
98-6455-2643-3868-3829-26

Last 5 Matchups

dateopponentscorespreadover/undermoneyline
Sep 22ndTBL 1-6-1.5 LO 6TB -130
Sep 22ndTBW 2-0-1.5 WU 6.5NYY -145
Sep 20th@ARIL 4-8+1.5 LO 8.5ARI +104
Sep 20th@ARIL 3-5-1.5 LO 7.5ARI -160
Sep 19th@ARIW 9-2-1.5 WO 7.5NYY -106

Rays vs. Yankees Injury Updates

Rays Injuries

    Yankees Injuries

    • Clarke Schmidt
      SP

      Schmidt is out with elbow

      Out

    Rays vs. Yankees Box Score
    Rays Player Stats
    Projected
    PITCHERPCIPKER
    Mason Englert logoRM.Englert, P863.268
    Casey Legumina logoRC.Legumina, P231.110
    Brody Hopkins logoRB.Hopkins, P16120
    Steven Matz logoLS.Matz, P23110
    Cole Sulser logoRC.Sulser, P25111
    HITTERSH-ABRHRRBI
    Victor Mesa logo1V.Mesa, LF0-3000
    Jonathan Aranda logo2J.Aranda, DH0-4000
    Junior Caminero logo3J.Caminero, 3B0-2000
    Nick Fortes logo3N.Fortes, PH0-2000
    Nick Fortes logo3N.Fortes, C0-2000
    Liam Hicks logo4L.Hicks, C0-2100
    Liam Hicks logo4L.Hicks, 1B0-2100
    Jonny DeLuca logo5J.DeLuca, RF3-4001
    Richie Palacios logo6R.Palacios, 2B1-4000
    Ryan Vilade logo7R.Vilade, 1B0-4000
    Ryan Vilade logo7R.Vilade, 3B0-4000
    Cedric Mullins logo8C.Mullins, CF1-4111
    Jorge Mateo logo9J.Mateo, SS1-4000
    Yankees Player Stats
    Projected
    PITCHERPCIPKER
    Gerrit Cole logoRG.Cole, P1055.282
    Brent Headrick logoLB.Headrick, P20.100
    John Schreiber logoRJ.Schreiber, P70.100
    Tim Hill logoLT.Hill, P70.200
    Paul Blackburn logoRP.Blackburn, P15100
    David Bednar logoRD.Bednar, P16110
    HITTERSH-ABRHRRBI
    Ben Rice logo1B.Rice, DH3-4222
    George Lombard logo2G.Lombard, SS1-5111
    Luis Garcia logo3L.Garcia, 1B1-4100
    Heliot Ramos logo4H.Ramos, RF2-4001
    Spencer Jones logo5S.Jones, CF1-5100
    Jazz Chisholm logo6J.Chisholm, 2B1-3100
    Jose Caballero logo7J.Caballero, LF0-3100
    Ryan McMahon logo8R.McMahon, 3B2-4115
    Ali Sanchez logo9A.Sanchez, C1-4100

    Rays vs. Yankees Odds Comparison

    Right Arrow

    Could not load odds

    Rays at Yankees Team Totals

    MatchupOverUnder
    Rays
    8-6
    N/A
    N/A
    Yankees
    2-3
    N/A
    N/A