The midterms are over, but the political fights of 2026 aren’t done yet. Chuck Schumer’s grip on the top Senate Democratic job is facing its most serious test in years. Chris Van Hollen has stepped forward to challenge him for the post, and while prediction markets still put Schumer well ahead, the race has pulled in enough senators that the Dec. 1 vote is no longer a formality.
Van Hollen Announces a Challenge to Schumer for Senate Majority Leader
Van Hollen made it official on Thursday, telling MS NOW he was entering the race for Senate Majority Leader. He framed the move as a response to the midterms rather than a personal shot at Schumer, saying “we need new leadership.”
Democrats flipped 8 seats in November and will hold at least 55 seats once the new Congress convenes in January, numbers strong enough, Van Hollen argued, that the party can afford a real debate over who runs the caucus. Schumer answered within hours, pointing to the midterm results and declaring:
“I have the votes to continue serving as Democratic leader.”
The caucus will settle the question in a secret ballot on Dec. 1.
Schumer vs. Van Hollen Odds Today
Prediction markets, like Kalshi and Polymarket, still favor Schumer by a wide margin, though Van Hollen has gained ground since the announcement.
| Candidate | Kalshi | Polymarket |
| Chuck Schumer | 86% | 86% |
| Chris Van Hollen | 13% | 15% |
Both markets price in a comfortable Schumer win, but the Dec. 1 vote is a closed caucus ballot, not a public primary: these numbers reflect how traders read the senators’ private math, not an actual count.
Grab the Kalshi promo code, and read our Kalshi review.
Who’s Backing Whom: Sanders, Slotkin, El-Sayed, Flanagan and the Freshman Class
Van Hollen’s clearest supporter so far is Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed, who had floated Van Hollen’s name for weeks and endorsed him the moment he entered the race. Bernie Sanders and Elissa Slotkin made a joint appearance this week calling for new leadership, with Sanders saying:
“I will not be supporting Chuck to be reelected as the Democratic leader.”
Incoming senators Peggy Flanagan, Troy Jackson, Adam Hamilton and Annie Andrews have also said it’s time for someone else at the top.
Schumer isn’t short on allies, either. Angus King, Sherrod Brown, John Fetterman, Ruben Gallego, Kirsten Gillibrand, Mark Kelly, Jacky Rosen, Brian Schatz and Sheldon Whitehouse have all backed him publicly, crediting the party’s unexpectedly strong midterm showing.
Download the Action Network app for more politics and prediction markets analysis.
How the Dec. 1 Secret-Ballot Vote Works
The leadership fight won’t play out in public. Senate Democrats pick their leader behind closed doors by secret ballot, and Schumer only needs a simple majority of the caucus to keep the job. That gives Van Hollen roughly 3 weeks to lock down commitments: he says he currently has more than 10 senators on his side and expects that number to grow now that his bid is official. By his own admission, he’s still the underdog.
Want to read more about politics? Visit Prediction Pro.
Why Now: A 55-Seat Majority and the Party’s Divisions
The timing says a lot about where Senate Democrats stand. Winning control of the chamber hasn’t settled the party’s internal fights: if anything, it’s sharpened them. Progressives have pushed back on Schumer over what they see as reluctance to confront President Donald Trump directly, along with his comfort with outside groups weighing in on primaries. Van Hollen has leaned into that frustration, promising to use the “full power” of the Senate on issues like ending the Iran war and lowering costs, and pledging to stay out of future primaries the way Schumer hasn’t.
What To Watch Before Dec. 1
Expect both camps to keep rolling out endorsements in the days ahead. Watch whether Van Hollen can turn his early support among incoming senators into real numbers among sitting Democrats, and whether Schumer’s public confidence holds once more members go on record. The odds on Kalshi and Polymarket will likely keep moving with every name that lines up on either side.
If you want more Action Network content, be sure to add us as a preferred source on Google.
