Mets vs. Yankees Odds & Betting Predictions - May 17, 2025

Mets at Yankees

5:05 pm • YES

New York Mets

28-17

2 - 2

New York Yankees

26-18

MatchupOpenSpreadTotalMoneyline
Mets 28-17	+1.5	+1.5-175	o10-112	+115
Yankees 26-18	u9.5	-1.5+145	u10-105	-135

Saturday 5:05 p.m.

May 17, 2025

Yankee StadiumBronx

NYY -127 (Live)

1.27u

NYM +114

J.Soto o1.5 Total Bases+122

J.Soto o1.5 Hits + Runs + RBIs-120

1.2u

NYM +115

Under 10-110

1.1u

Good teams under Overall: 303-206-26,60% (ROI:14%) Season:7-6-1,54% (ROI:3%)

NYM +120

Subway Series revenge angle—Mets haven’t lost 3 straight all year. Canning red-hot: 2.36 ERA, 5 straight wins. Bullpen lights out: 2.39 ERA last 109.1 IP. Schmidt hittable (4.73 ERA), gives up loud contact. Mets rank 5th OPS, 10th runs—offense due for a bounce. Canning’s control unmatched—42 Ks in 42 IP, opp batting .216. Mets team ERA near 2.84—best in majors. Bullpen rested + elite, won’t waste a lead. Yankees 0-5 last 5 day games off a win. Mets 12-3 after losses, 8-1 RL as road dogs off B2Bs. Momentum flips today. Soto quiet Friday, still holds .380 OBP—prime spot to pop vs Schmidt. Alonso raking: .303 AVG, 9 HR, .635 SLG. Lindor also hitting .294, 9 HR. Mets went 4-0 vs Yanks in 2024. Dogs have won 4 of last 5 in this rivalry.

Over 9.5-110

0.55u

Bet to -115

Mets vs. Yankees: Target the Under Saturday
Tony Sartori•
May 17, 2025 UTC
Our 3 MLB Best Bets for Saturday
Action Network Staff•
May 17, 2025 UTC

See more MLB Coverage

No props found

MLB Public Betting

Yankees are 4-1 in their last 5 games.
Yankees are 3-2 in their last 5 games against the spread
Yankees are 10-12 in their road games against the spread
The totals have gone OVER in 2 of Yankees' last 5 games
The totals have gone OVER in 10 of Yankees' 22 last games at home

Against the Spread (ATS) History

	overall	home	away	favorite	underdog
Yankees	23-21	13-9	10-12	21-17	2-4
Mets	21-24	12-10	9-14	15-19	6-5

Over/Under History

	overall	home o/u	away o/u	favorite o/u	underdog o/u
Yankees	20-22-2	10-12	10-10-2	18-19-1	2-3-1
Mets	16-28-1	7-14-1	9-14	16-17-1	0-11

Straight-Up (ML) History

	overall	home	away	favorite	underdog
Yankees	26-18	14-8	12-10	25-13	1-5
Mets	28-17	17-5	11-12	23-11	5-6

date	opponent	score	spread	over/under	moneyline
May 16th	NYM	W 6-2	-1.5 W	U 9	NYY -147
May 14th	@SEA	W 3-2	-1.5 L	U 8	NYY -115
May 14th	@SEA	L 1-2	-1.5 L	U 7.5	SEA -145
May 13th	@SEA	W 11-5	-1.5 W	O 8	NYY -152
May 11th	@ATH	W 12-2	-1.5 W	O 11	NYY -148

Frankie Montas
P
Montas is out with back
Out
Sean Manaea
P
Manaea is out with oblique
Out
Paul Blackburn
P
Blackburn is out with knee
Out
Jose Siri
OF
Siri is out with leg
Out
Nick Madrigal
IF
Madrigal is out with shoulder
Out
Ronny Mauricio
IF
Mauricio is out with knee
Out
Christian Scott
P
Scott is out for season with elbow
Out for Season

Gerrit Cole
P
Cole is out for season with elbow
Out for Season
Giancarlo Stanton
DH
Stanton is out with elbow
Out
Luis Gil
P
Gil is out with back
Out
JT Brubaker
P
Brubaker is out with ribs
Out

See more MLB Injuries

PITCHER		PC	IP	K	ER
RG.Canning, P		92	5.1	4	2
RH.Brazoban, P		20	1.2	1	0

HITTERS	H-AB	R	RBI
1F.Lindor, SS	0-3	1	0
2J.Soto, RF	1-2	1	0
3P.Alonso, 1B	1-3	0	1
4B.Nimmo, LF	0-2	0	0
5M.Vientos, DH	0-2	0	1
6J.McNeil, 2B	0-2	0	0
7L.Torrens, C	1-2	0	0
8B.Baty, 3B	0-3	0	0
9T.Taylor, CF	1-3	0	0

PITCHER		PC	IP	K	ER
RC.Schmidt, P		88	6	5	2
RM.Leiter, P		8	1	0	0

HITTERS	H-AB	R	HR	RBI
1B.Rice, DH	1-4	0	0	0
2A.Judge, RF	0-4	0	0	0
3C.Bellinger, CF	1-3	1	1	1
4P.Goldschmidt, 1B	0-3	0	0	0
5J.Dominguez, LF	2-3	0	0	0
6A.Volpe, SS	1-3	0	0	0
7J.Escarra, C	0-2	0	0	0
8D.LeMahieu, 2B	2-3	1	1	1
9J.Vivas, 3B	0-2	0	0	0
9T.Grisham, PH	0-1	0	0	0