Astros vs. Yankees ALCS Game 3 Betting Picks, Odds & Predictions: Back Yankees as a Home Underdog Against Cole?

Astros vs. Yankees ALCS Game 3 Betting Picks, Odds & Predictions: Back Yankees as a Home Underdog Against Cole? article feature image

Troy Taormina, USA Today Sports. Pictured: Gerrit Cole

  • The betting odds for Tuesday's Astros-Yankees game opened with Houston as a -148 moneyline favorite, with the over/under at 7.5.
  • The updated odds show the over/under has remained the same (7.5), with the moneyline shifting to Astros -150.
  • Our MLB expert Sean Zerillo breaks down his picks for Game 3.

Astros vs. Yankees Betting Picks, Odds & Predictions for Game 3

Probable starters: Gerrit Cole (20-5, 2.50 ERA) vs. Luis Severino (1-1 1.50 ERA)

  • Astros odds:  -160
  • Yankees odds: +135
  • Over/Under:  7.5
  • First pitch:  4:08 p.m. ET on FS1

The Astros and Yankees meet in the Bronx today for the first of three meetings in the Bronx over the next three days, following their epic ALCS Game 2; which Houston won on a walk-off homer by George Springer in extras.

Bullpen management will be crucial in Game 3, with both teams playing for three consecutive days, and each slated to throw bullpen games on Wednesday.

As a result, both clubs will be looking for length out of their Game 3 starters.

Odds as of Tuesday morning and via PointsBet, where Action Network users get an exclusive 200% deposit match (deposit $50, bet with $150).

The Astros will turn to Gerrit Cole — the AL Cy Young front-runner who has looked nearly invincible over two playoff starts – allowing one run against 25 strikeouts over 15.2 innings against the Rays.

The Yankees will counter with Luis Severino, a pitcher who has been an ace over the past two seasons but was limited to three starts in 2019 due to injury.

Can Severino provide a quality outing to match Cole, and help the Yankees to a Game 3 win?

The Starters

From June 1 to the end of the regular season, Gerrit Cole posted a 1.73 ERA, pitching his way into Cy Young contention before he heads into free agency.

He was ridiculous in the ALDS against the Rays, generating 52 swinging strikes in 15.2 innings over two starts.

But can the Yankees potent offense break through against Cole in Game 3?

I featured Cole before his Game 2 start and again before his win or go home Game 5 start when he was fantastic at home, tossing his 11th consecutive start with double-digit strikeouts.

I have noted the following things about Gerrit Cole:

  • Led the American League in FIP (2.68), xFIP (2.48), WAR (7.4) and strikeouts (326)
  • Eliminated his sinker usage since joining the Astros, partially leading to the uptick in performance
  • Increased his swinging strike rate to an MLB best 16.8% this season
  • Owns the second-fastest fastball in MLB, which was the most valuable pitch of the 2019 season

He generated whiffs everywhere against the Rays, in another visually impressive performance:

Gerrit Cole's 10 Strikeouts, Overlay (synced at release)

— Rob Friedman (@PitchingNinja) October 11, 2019

As you can see, he was particularly good at making Rays hitters chase pitches outside of the zone:

While Cole ranked 13th amongst 61 qualified starters in chase rate, he led all pitchers with a 49.1% contact rate on those pitches.

It’s yet another area where he has made significant gains since joining the Astros:

I touched on Luis Severino before his Game 3 start against the Twins, when he tossed four shutout innings.

I have some concerns about the Yankees’ righty as he continues to stretch out after missing most of the season with shoulder and lat injuries.

But he generated 13 called strikes and 10 whiffs against the Twins and appeared to be sharp in his final tuneup before facing the Astros:

With the bases loaded and nobody out, Luis Severino didn't blink 😤


— SI MLB (@si_mlb) October 8, 2019

However, Severino continues to live at a slightly lower velocity (one mph slower) than where he has been over the past two seasons:

He will also have to overcome two poor outings against the Astros in the 2017 ALCS when he allowed four runs over 8.2 combined innings (five hits, six walks, three strikeouts) as the Yankees fell in seven games.

I have made it clear that, when healthy, Severino is the Yankees’ No. 1 pitcher – ahead of Masahiro Tanaka or James Paxton.

Between the 2017-2018 seasons, Severino developed into one of the best starters in the game, ranking eighth starters in FIP (3.01) and fifth in xFIP (3.07):

The Bullpens

On the season, the Astros bullpen ranks 11th in FIP, 1st in xFIP, and 1st in K-BB%. By the same metrics, the Yankees rank 9th, 4th, and 6th.

Josh James and Ryan Pressly were the only Astros relievers to pitch in the first two games of this series, though Pressly’s postseason struggles continue.

Roberto Osuna was Houston’s only reliever who tossed more than 20 pitches in Game 2.

Conversely, the Yankees deployed Aroldis Chapman (25 pitches), Chad Green (26 pitches), and Tommy Kahnle (25 pitches) for longer outings after James Paxton was pulled early.

Additionally, Zack Britton, Jonathan Loaisiga, and Adam Ottavino all pitched in Games 1 and 2.

With a bullpen game looming on Wednesday, Aaron Boone can’t necessarily afford to have another quick hook with Severino, as he did with Paxton in Game 2.

Projected Lineups

Data per FantasyLabs

Umpire and Weather Report

Data per Sports Insights

Unders at Yankee Stadium went 44-37-2 (54.3%) in 2019, and are 21-17 in playoff games dating back to 2005.

Jeff Nelson is set to work as the plate umpire. Nelson is a relatively neutral umpire for totals, with a 51.8% career lean to the under, including a 4-2-1 record in postseason games.

Nelson is a terrific umpire for underdogs, at 231-246 (48.4%), generating a consistent $100 bettor $5,324

Home underdogs are 89-78 (53.3%, +$2,714) under Nelson’s watch.

Trends to Know

The Yankees went 6-4 as a home underdog in 2019, but have not been a home underdog in a playoff game since 2010; when they lost 8-0 to the Texas Rangers.

The Yankees are 24-14 (63.2%) in home playoff games since 2005 but have only generated a consistent $100 bettor +$8.

Over the same period, the Astros are just 2-4 as a road favorite in the playoffs.

Overs are 50-32-2 (61%) in Luis Severino’s regular season and postseason starts, and 35-31-3 (53%) in Gerrit Cole’s starts over the past two years.

Gerrit Cole is 39-15-11 (72.2%) on the F5 moneyline over the past two seasons.

Luis Severino is 40-19-7 (67.8%) on the F5 moneyline over the past three seasons, including a 5-3-1 record as an underdog.

Series Moneyline Corner

Before Game 2, I noted that I would project the Astros as a -127 series favorite with a win to even the ALCS at 1-1.

Before Game 3, oddsmakers re-opened the Astros as a -160 favorite and listed the Yankees as a +140 underdog

Therefore, I see slight series moneyline value on the Yankees; and I would consider playing them at +145 (implied 40.8%) or higher.

That number represents a gap of more than three percent in expected value from my projection (+127, implied 44.1%).

However, holding an AL Pennant Ticket on Houston (+200), I’m not personally inclined to play the Yankees to win the AL pennant.

If the Astros win on Tuesday to take a 2-1 series lead, I will project Houston as a -285  series favorite (implied 74%) to win two out of the final four games.

With an Astros loss to go down 1-2 on the road, I would list the Yankees as a -170 series favorite (implied 63%).

Model Projected Odds

Favorite Bet 

I projected the Astros as a -136 favorite in this game, and I set the total at 7.8 runs. Therefore, I don’t see any value on the total, but I did make a couple of plays on the Yankees moneyline. 

I played a half unit on the Yankees moneyline at +153 (implied 39.5%), which represented a gap of nearly three percent in expected value from my projection (42.4%).

However, the Yankees moneyline has ticked down since, and I now prefer their first five innings (F5) moneyline; as I would need to see +150 or higher to recommend the game moneyline.

I projected the Yankees as a +118 F5 underdog and played their F5 moneyline for a half unit at +160 (implied 38.5%) – which represents a gap of more than seven percent from my projection (+118, implied 45.9%).

I would play the F5 moneyline down to +136 (implied 42.4%) – which still represents an expected value gap of 3.5% from my number.

How would you rate this article?