HomeRight ArrowNCAAF

College Football Picks, Predictions: A Lookahead Upset Spot for NCAAF Week 2

College Football Picks, Predictions: A Lookahead Upset Spot for NCAAF Week 2 article feature image
4 min read
Credit:

BRYAN TERRY/THE OKLAHOMAN / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images. Pictured: Oklahoma State QB Drew Mestemaker.

The college football offseason is entirely too long.

By the time North Carolina and TCU take the field in Dublin, Ireland, it will have been 221 days since Indiana and Miami met in the College Football Playoff National Championship game.

That much dead time can lead to a bit of groupthink. One common refrain from college football pundits is that the early portion of the schedule is light on marquee matchups and likely to produce very few upsets.

Last season featured three top-10 matchups in Week 1 alone, but if we’ve learned anything about college football over the years, it’s that the quiet weeks are the ones you have to worry about.

There's one matchup with a huge point spread in the lookahead market that has the potential to shake up the AP Poll and the national title pecking order.

Let's dive into my college football picks and NCAAF predictions for Week 2.


Oregon vs Oklahoma State Pick

Oregon Logo
Saturday, Sep 12
12 p.m. ET
ESPN
OK State Logo
Oregon Odds
SpreadTotalMoneyline
-17.5
-105
59.5
-105o / -115u
-900
OK State Odds
SpreadTotalMoneyline
+17.5
-115
59.5
-105o / -115u
+590
Odds via FanDuel. Get up-to-the-minute NCAAF odds here.
FanDuel Logo

Over the past 20 years, Stillwater and Boone Pickens Stadium have earned a reputation as a graveyard for ranked opponents.

The Cowboys have racked up 36 wins over AP Top 25 opponents in the past two decades, the 10th-most nationally. They’ve also won outright as a home underdog 40% of the time, placing them 10th among their power conference peers.

They fared even better against the spread, covering 56% of the time, which ranks eighth among P4 teams. And this accounts for Oklahoma State’s dreadful run across the past two seasons.

Speaking of OSU bottoming out, the Pokes’ 4-20 record straight up and 8-16 mark against the spread since 2024 have created two advantageous angles in this game.

Header First Logo

Oklahoma State's 2 Key Advantages

The first element is recency bias. The lasting image of OSU football from last season came during a 69-3 loss to these same Oregon Ducks. That will artificially keep this point spread above 17 points.

The second element working in OSU’s favor came in late September when Oklahoma State AD Chad Weiberg fired head coach Mike Gundy, making way for a new coaching staff and the sport’s largest transfer portal class (55 signees, ranked 15th).

Head coach Eric Morris arrives from North Texas after leading the Mean Green to their first double-digit-win season since 1977.

His offense was perfectly balanced, featuring the nation’s passing yardage leader in Drew Mestemaker and the first freshman running back to lead the nation in rushing touchdowns in 13 years in Caleb Hawkins.

Both have followed Morris up I-35, giving Oklahoma State the kind of firepower to catch a national power like Oregon off guard.

Big 12 Win Totals, Picks, Predictions: 2026 College Football Preview for Texas Tech, BYU, Utah, More Image
Header First Logo

Where Could Oregon Struggle?

On the Oregon side of things, we have Dante Moore, a Heisman hopeful and a major contender to become next spring’s No. 1 overall pick in the NFL Draft (+400).

Yet, Moore has struggled a bit away from Eugene, especially when facing a quality opponent. Last season, he was masterful in blowouts and shaky nip-and-tuck affairs.

In games that Oregon won by 15-plus points, he completed 74% of his pass attempts while posting a sterling touchdown-to-interception ratio of 15:4.

But when Oregon found itself in a dogfight, Moore crumpled. In losses to Indiana (twice) and a narrow escape at Iowa, his completion percentage dipped (61%), his sack rate spiked (nine sacks). His TD-to-INT ratio also came back down to earth at 3:4.

The Pokes' new defensive coordinator, Skyler Cassity, is the kind of play-caller who can give Moore issues. He elegantly blends sim pressures, overload blitzes and trap coverages that generate poor decisions from opposing passers.

Under Cassity’s leadership, North Texas picked off 15 passes last fall to rank 14th nationally in that area. In 2024, as Sam Houston’s DC, Cassity found more magic, leading one of the nation’s best defensive turnarounds.

He knows how to whip a defense into shape, and luckily, he has at least one elite unit to start with.

Transfer Ethan Wesloski (UNT) and Isaiah Chisom (UCLA) are tackling machines at linebacker. If they anchor a respectable run defense, Cassity’s pressure packages will bother Moore on passing downs.

Header First Logo

Oregon vs Oklahoma State Prediction

Oklahoma State’s cut-and-paste approach has the potential to be a home run offensively, and I firmly believe Cassity is the kind of coach who can squeeze every ounce of potential out of a defense filled with new faces.

At +600, I’m swinging for the fences and calling my shot on the year’s first colossal upset.

Pick: Oklahoma State ML +600

This site contains commercial content. We may be compensated for the links provided on this page. The content on this page is for informational purposes only. Action Network makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the information given or the outcome of any game or event.