2023-24 National Title Contenders & Final Four Dark Horse Candidates Entering Conference Play

2023-24 National Title Contenders & Final Four Dark Horse Candidates Entering Conference Play article feature image
Credit:

Photo by Katharine Lotze/Getty Images

During the Spring of 2019, I authored two recurring college basketball futures columns as a writer at Action Network. Those columns were titled, "College Basketball National Title Contenders" and "Final Four Dark Horse Candidates."

Since then, it has become tradition that I revisit those columns each college basketball season.

The goal of this article is to help you isolate the specific teams with viable paths to the Final Four and to explicitly exclude other teams from plausible contention.

My hope is that this discrimination of contenders vs. pretenders will help you build more viable (and more financially lucrative) futures portfolios in preparation for NCAA tournament play.


What Qualifies a Team as a "National Championship Contender?"

For a thorough explanation of my full methods, refer to my original National Title Contenders and Final Four Dark Horses articles from the 2018-19 season.

But, as a concise summary, teams qualify as National Championship Contenders by achieving three metrical thresholds, each sourced from Ken Pomeroy and adjusted each offseason based on previous postseason results.

  • Adjusted Offensive Efficiency (AdjO) of 114.0 or higher.
  • Adjusted Defensive Efficiency (AdjD) of 96.2 or lower.
  • Adjusted Efficiency Margin (AdjEM) of 23.81 or higher.

Adjusted Offensive Efficiency (AdjO): Points scored per 100 possessions, adjusted for opponents

Adjusted Defensive Efficiency (AdjD): Points allowed per 100 possessions, adjusted for opponents

Adjusted Efficiency Margin (AdjEM): The difference between a team's offensive and defensive efficiency

These thresholds correspond precisely with statistically significant and discriminating z-scores among our sample population of teams since the 2001-02 season.

Furthermore — and this point is very important — there is no statistically significant improvement in a team's odds to win the national championship beyond these prescribed threshold values.

However, it is imperative that a team meets all three of these metrical thresholds in order for the preceding statement to hold true. Independently, each metric still reports statistically significant improvement in a team's title odds up to approximately z=+2.00.


National Championship Contenders from Previous Seasons

During the 2018-19 college basketball season — when this perennial column originally debuted — 10 teams qualified as National Championship Contenders by the end of the regular season: Virginia, Gonzaga, Duke, Michigan State, North Carolina, Michigan, Tennessee, Kentucky, Purdue and Virginia Tech.

During the 2020-21 season, the list of National Championship Contenders was notably shorter. Only six teams made the cut that year: Gonzaga, Illinois, Michigan, Baylor, Iowa and Houston.

In 2021-22, 10 teams made the cut, including: Gonzaga, Arizona, Kentucky, Baylor, Houston, Duke, Auburn, UCLA, Kansas and Villanova.

Finally, last season the list narrowed again to only six contenders entering postseason play: Houston, UCLA, Alabama, UConn, Texas and Purdue.

Altogether, that gives us a sample of 32 total teams distinguished as National Championship Contenders during the past four NCAA tournaments. Here's how those 32 teams have collectively performed:

  • 30 teams advanced to the Round of 32.
  • 26 teams advanced to the Sweet 16.
  • 16 teams advanced to the Elite 8.
  • 10 teams booked a trip to the Final Four.

Among the teams that qualified as National Championship Contenders in each season, all four groups included the eventual national champion ('19 Virginia, '21 Baylor'22 Kansas and '23 UConn).

Moreover, nine of the 32 teams exited their respective tournaments by losing to other end-of-season National Championship Contenders.


2023-24 National Championship Contenders

After cross-referencing 2023-24 teams with an AdjEM of 23.81 or higher, AdjO of 114.0 or higher and AdjD of 96.2 or lower, six teams qualify as National Championship Contenders as of writing (Thursday, Dec. 21):

TeamAdjEMAdjOAdjD
31.561117.31685.81
30.402119.4689.02
29.893122.9293.012
26.254120.8394.519
25.185117.51492.39
23.936114.93091.04
Phone With the Action App Open
The must-have app for college basketball bettors
The best NCAAB betting scoreboard
Free picks from proven pros
Live win probabilities for your bets

2023-24 Final Four Dark Horse Contenders

Once teams make it to the Final Four, AdjO and AdjD lose much of their statistical strength as factors that discriminate champions from non-champions.

Instead, at this advanced stage of the tournament, the sole metric that still reports a significant Pearson's coefficient is AdjEM. Therefore, if you're trying to identify a national champion, you should prioritize AdjEM as the most distinguishing factor.

However, if instead you're trying to identify sneaky Final Four teams that might bust others' brackets, then the combination of AdjO and AdjD remains an effective tool to identify these relative long shots.

By excluding AdjEM as a required threshold, our resultant qualifying sample of teams includes significantly more Final Four teams.

Nevertheless, this wider net also catches far more teams that make early tournament exits. Thus, it is necessarily a higher-risk / higher-reward strategy to intentionally target these Final Four Dark Horse teams.

Through the bulk of non-conference play this season, eight additional teams qualify as Final Four Dark Horse candidates based on our prescribed methods:

TeamAdjOAdjD
117.61294.117
118.9795.630
115.02993.113
116.12294.218
116.51795.022
116.12395.125
115.32595.931
115.22795.932

Notable Teams That Do Not Qualify as National Championship Contenders Nor Final Four Dark Horses

In addition to highlighting the set of teams that can win a championship — or at least make the Final Four — it is also valuable to identify the specific teams that do not make the cut.

These are teams that may make the Sweet 16, and may disrupt brackets in the process, but shouldn't be trusted to make it all the way to the Final Four.

TeamAdjEMAdjOAdjD
22.0011118.51096.540
21.9313118.6896.741
21.9114113.33891.46
21.3818120.7499.371
20.5920112.84692.28
20.3821117.51597.146

The new ESPN Sportsbook is now online and you can use Action’s ESPN BET promo code TANBONUS for a new user welcome.


How would you rate this article?

This site contains commercial content. We may be compensated for the links provided on this page. The content on this page is for informational purposes only. Action Network makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the information given or the outcome of any game or event.

Sportsbook Promos
See All
Legal Online Sports Betting

bet365 Bonus Code TOPACTION: Land a $150 Sign Up Bonus or $1K Insurance Offer on Monday, All Week

Nick Sterling
Jul 15, 2024 UTC