Red Sox vs. Yankees Odds & Betting Predictions - October 1, 2025

Red Sox at Yankees

10:08 pm • ESPN
3 - 4
Starting Pitchers
pitcherteameraw-l
Carlos Rodon logoC.RodonNew York Yankees logo0.000-0
Brayan Bello logoB.BelloBoston Red Sox logo0.000-0

Red Sox at Yankees Odds

Spread, Total, Moneyline

MatchupOpenSpreadTotalMoneyline
Red Sox
1-1
+1.5
+1.5-124
o7.5-118
+169
Yankees
1-1
u7
-1.5+106
u7.5-106
-202
location pinWednesday 10:08 p.m.
October 01, 2025
Yankee StadiumBronx
Red Sox vs. Yankees Expert Picks
VegasIsMyBitch
VegasIsMyBitch
Last 30d: 9-16-0 (-4.0u)
NYY -1.5+120
1u
Boomer Betz
Boomer Betz
Last 30d: 124-106-2 (+21.8u)
Over 7.5+100
1u
YBK Picks.com
Last 30d: 42-39-2 (-0.6u)
NYY -1-135
2u
💰🦡 Jake
💰🦡 Jake
Last 30d: 100-124-6 (+28.3u)
NYY -0.5 (F5)-125
1.5u
Picks Office
Picks Office
Last 30d: 60-83-3 (-19.6u)
BOS +160
1u
Sir Lockselot
Sir Lockselot
Last 30d: 31-58-0 (-14.9u)
G.Stanton o0.5 RBI+183
1.5u
📚Player Profit 🔑 G.Stanton o0.5 RBI +183 (Player Profit) 1.5u Betalytics x SL ⚾️ play Stanton- 5 ⭐️ grade, 🟢 matchup, 41.8% expected win probability For BA tools 👉 https://www.betalytics.com/ Promo code: LOCKSELOT for 25% off Code: sirlocks for 10% off every deposit at https://www.playerprofit.com/ Let’s cash
The Pick Don
The Pick Don
Last 30d: 26-19-0 (+3.8u)
NYY -0.5 (F5)-115
1.5u
This is not a spot I can trust Brayan Bello. He’s been good this season, but his underlying metrics present some concern. Bello currently has a 3.35 ERA, but a 4.42 xERA, 4.19 FIP, 4.39 xFIP, and 4.55 SIERA. He’s been fortunate this season, largely due to his .268 BABIP and 75.3% left-on-base percentage. Considering his career BABIP of .305, that .268 mark is unlikely to be sustainable. Bello is also posting a career low botERA, Stuff+, and Pitching+ grade. His fastball is his only above average pitch, and he’s striking out just 17.7% of batters. The one concern with the Yankees offense is their strikeout rate, which is why it’s important to target pitchers with low strikeout rates against them. Speaking of the Yankees offense, this unit is elite and has a much better lineup out tonight. New York has the best offense in baseball with a 119 wRC+ and has been smoking the ball over the last month. I will say, Bello has been sharp against the Yankees this season, but this is a whole new challenge. Bello has never pitched in the postseason before, and this is a very tough environment and spot to make your postseason debut. I was a big advocate of fading Carlos Rodón last season, but this is a totally different pitcher. Rodon is an entirely different pitcher this season and he’s currently having the best season of his career since leaving the Giants. He’s cleaned up his home run problem with just a 2.8% home run rate compared to 4.2% and 5.2% in the two previous seasons. His fastball went from a liability pitch to one of the best in baseball, with a 12 run value that ranks in the 91st percentile. Rodón’s fastball is getting 4.2 inches of horizontal break compared to just 2.5 inches last year, and that’s significantly improved his ground ball rate to 44% compared to just 34.6% last season. His .215 xBA is excellent, and he’s been great when facing the Red Sox lineup. Across 132 plate appearances against Rodón, the Red Sox are hitting just .228. As mentioned yesterday, since Roman Anthony and Marcelo Mayer went down with injuries, the Red Sox offense ranks just 22nd in the league with an 86 wRC+. I’ll avoid the New York bullpen and will take the Yankees F5 innings -.5.
Player Prop Savant
Player Prop Savant
Last 30d: 31-23-0 (+4.7u)
C.Rodon u15.5 Outs-125
1.25u
Moneyline Hacks
Moneyline Hacks
Last 30d: 113-131-7 (+45.9u)
Under 4 (F5)-110
1u
🚨Free analysis & VIP Picks can be found on our Discord. Link: https://discord.gg/JrzjtqdVfA 🎙️Fade the Noise PODCAST - Subscribe!✅ https://www.youtube.com/@FadetheNoise 🔥50% OFF VIP!! ⬇️⬇️ (COPY & PASTE LINK): https://dubclub.win/r/p/pri-r744p/?checkout=1&coupon=ValueHacks50
Grant Neiffer
Grant Neiffer
Last 30d: 40-122-7 (-1.0u)
G.Stanton o0.5 HR+412
0.25u
A.Judge o0.5 HR+320
0.25u
Lines at Lunch
Lines at Lunch
Last 30d: 95-93-3 (-4.5u)
Under 4 (F5)-115
1.15u
Payoff Pitch Podcast
Payoff Pitch Podcast
Last 30d: 66-78-6 (+8.5u)
Under 7.5-120
0.83u
B.Bello u14.5 Outs+100
1u
C.Bellinger To Record 2+ Total Bases Yes+145
1u
C.Bellinger To Hit 1+ Home Runs Yes+625
0.25u
Sean Zerillo
Sean Zerillo
Last 30d: 152-176-7 (-13.9u)
B.Bello u14.5 Outs+100
0.1u
Bet to -120
Lines at Lunch
Lines at Lunch
Last 30d: 95-93-3 (-4.5u)
NYY -165
1u
Matt DiLeo
Matt DiLeo
Last 30d: 45-28-0 (+9.5u)
B.Bello u4.5 Ks-135
0.74u
Brandon Kravitz
Brandon Kravitz
Last 30d: 45-55-0 (-6.6u)
Under 7.5-120
1u
Brian Bitler
Brian Bitler
Last 30d: 74-73-1 (-5.5u)
BOS +1.5-144
2.08u
Kyle Murray
Kyle Murray
Last 30d: 54-51-4 (+7.4u)
Under 7.5-120
1u
Sandy Plashkes
Sandy Plashkes
Last 30d: 75-105-3 (-11.6u)
NYY -165
1u
Allan Lem
Allan Lem
Last 30d: 113-114-8 (-5.3u)
Under 7.5-105
1u
Sean Zerillo
Sean Zerillo
Last 30d: 152-176-7 (-13.9u)
Under 7.5-102
1u
Bet to -118

Red Sox vs. Yankees Previews & Analysis

  • MLB Betting Experts Are FADING Runs in Tigers vs Guardians! | MLB Playoff Best Bets | Payoff Pitch article feature image

    MLB Betting Experts Are FADING Runs in Tigers vs Guardians! | MLB Playoff Best Bets | Payoff Pitch

    Collin Whitchurch
    Oct 2, 2025 UTC
  • Red Sox vs Yankees: Yankees Have Early Edge article feature image

    Red Sox vs Yankees: Yankees Have Early Edge

    Nick Martin
    Oct 1, 2025 UTC
  • 2 MLB Playoff Strikeout Prop Picks for Wednesday article feature image

    2 MLB Playoff Strikeout Prop Picks for Wednesday

    Leo Tesler
    Oct 1, 2025 UTC
  • 3 MLB Playoffs Player Props for Wednesday article feature image

    3 MLB Playoffs Player Props for Wednesday

    Alex Hinton
    Oct 1, 2025 UTC
See more MLB Coverage Right Arrow

Prop Odds Comparison

Right Arrow
Right Arrow

No props found

Line Movement Tracker

Right Arrow
Right Arrow

Red Sox vs. Yankees Public Betting Percentages

Away Logo

Red Sox

Public

29%

Bets%

71%

Money%

Matchup History

Against the Spread (ATS) History

overallhomeawayfavoriteunderdog
Yankees
80-8235-4645-3662-7218-9
Red Sox
75-8732-4943-3830-4944-37

Over/Under History

overallhome o/uaway o/ufavorite o/uunderdog o/u
Yankees
87-69-645-33-342-36-376-54-411-14-2
Red Sox
79-75-837-40-442-35-437-40-241-34-6

Straight-Up (ML) History

overallhomeawayfavoriteunderdog
Yankees
8-644-3750-3176-5818-9
Red Sox
89-7338-4343-3842-3738-43

Last 5 Matchups

dateopponentscorespreadover/undermoneyline
Sep 30thBOSL 1-3-1.5 LU 6.5BOS -138
Sep 28thBALW 3-2-1.5 LU 8.5NYY -182
Sep 27thBALW 6-1-1.5 WU 9NYY -235
Sep 26thBALW 8-4-1.5 WO 8.5NYY -144
Sep 25thCWSW 5-3-1.5 WU 8.5NYY -310

Red Sox vs. Yankees Injury Updates

Red Sox Injuries

  • Jose De Leon
    RP

    De Leon is out with elbow

    Out

  • Tanner Houck
    SP

    Houck is out with arm

    Out

  • Patrick Sandoval
    SP

    Sandoval is out with elbow

    Out

  • Kutter Crawford
    SP

    Crawford is out with knee

    Out

  • Jovani Moran
    RP

    Moran is out with arm

    Out

Yankees Injuries

  • Gerrit Cole
    SP

    Cole is out for season with elbow

    Out for Season

Red Sox vs. Yankees Box Score
Red Sox Player Stats
Projected
PITCHERPCIPKER
Brayan Bello logoRB.Bello, P282.102
Justin Wilson logoLJ.Wilson, P231.200
Justin Slaten logoRJ.Slaten, P180.201
Steven Matz logoLS.Matz, P24110
Zachery Kelly logoRZ.Kelly, P60.110
Garrett Whitlock logoRG.Whitlock, P471.231
Payton Tolle logoLP.Tolle, P70.100
HITTERSH-ABRHRRBI
Robert Refsnyder logo1R.Refsnyder, DH0-3000
Masataka Yoshida logo1M.Yoshida, PH1-1000
Masataka Yoshida logo1M.Yoshida, DH1-1000
Trevor Story logo2T.Story, SS2-4113
Alexander Bregman logo3A.Bregman, 3B1-3000
Roman Gonzalez logo4R.Gonzalez, 1B0-3000
David Lowe logo4N.Lowe, PH0-1000
David Lowe logo4N.Lowe, 1B0-1000
Carlos Narvaez logo5C.Narvaez, C0-4000
Nathan Eaton logo6N.Eaton, RF1-2000
Wilyer Abreu logo6W.Abreu, PH0-1000
Jarren Duran logo7J.Duran, LF1-3100
Ceddanne Rafaela logo8C.Rafaela, CF0-3100
Nicholas Sogard logo9N.Sogard, 2B0-2000
Yankees Player Stats
Projected
PITCHERPCIPKER
Carlos Rodon logoLC.Rodon, P91663
Fernando Cruz logoRF.Cruz, P14100
Devin Williams logoRD.Williams, P19110
David Bednar logoRD.Bednar, P16120
HITTERSH-ABRHRRBI
Trenton Grisham logo1T.Grisham, CF1-4100
Aaron Judge logo2A.Judge, RF2-4001
Cody Bellinger logo3C.Bellinger, LF1-4100
Benjamin Rice logo4B.Rice, 1B2-4112
Paul Goldschmidt logo4P.Goldschmidt, 1B0-0000
Giancarlo Stanton logo5G.Stanton, DH0-4000
Jasrado Chisholm logo6J.Chisholm, 2B0-3100
Austin Wells logo7A.Wells, C2-3001
Anthony Volpe logo8A.Volpe, SS1-4000
Ryan McMahon logo9R.McMahon, 3B1-3000

Red Sox vs. Yankees Odds Comparison

Right Arrow

Could not load odds

Red Sox at Yankees Team Totals

MatchupOverUnder
Red Sox
1-1
o2.5-151
u2.5+119
Yankees
1-1
o4.5+100
u4.5-128