Turn your sports knowledge into winning predictions
21+ or 18+ in Certain Locations. 19+ in ON. Please Play Responsibly. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Visit connexontario.ca or Call 1-866-531-2600 in ON.
No Code Needed

Blue Jays vs. Yankees Odds & Betting Predictions - October 8, 2025

Blue Jays at Yankees

12:08 am • Fox Sports 1

Toronto Blue Jays

3-1
6
6 - 9

New York Yankees

1-3
9
Starting Pitchers
pitcherteameraw-l
Carlos Rodon logoC.RodonNew York Yankees logo9.720-0
Shane Bieber logoS.BieberToronto Blue Jays logo3.862-1

Blue Jays at Yankees Odds

Spread, Total, Moneyline

MatchupOpenSpreadTotalMoneyline
Blue Jays
3-1
+1.5
+1.5-144
o8-115
+144
Yankees
1-3
u8
-1.5+120
u8-106
-171
location pinWednesday 12:08 a.m.
October 08, 2025
Yankee StadiumBronx
Blue Jays vs. Yankees Expert Picks
YBK Picks.com
Last 30d: 45-37-3 (+17.0u)
NYY -1-120
1.67u
Over 8-120
1.67u
Sean Zerillo
Sean Zerillo
Last 30d: 139-122-5 (+5.3u)
TOR +130
1u
Update: Bet to +125 after lineups
Over 7.5-110
0.5u
Bet to 8 (+100)
Over 7.5-120
0.2u
Market finally shoved the Over 7.5. Ok to pick up the remainder at -120 or 8 (+100)
Kenny Ducey
Kenny Ducey
Last 30d: 1-2-0 (-1.2u)
NYY -145 (F5)
1u
Matt Trollo
Matt Trollo
Last 30d: 10-14-1 (-0.8u)
Over 7.5-110
0.5u
Temps stay in 70s, Bieber has a hard hit rate problem against a dangerous lineup, while the Blue Jays have thumped LHP this year and all Yankee pitchers in this series.
TOR +124
0.5u
Both SPs have had ups and downs, but grade out closely, in the upper 3s - NYY 117/118 wRC+ Hm/v RHP, TOR 105/111 - comparable bullpens - TOR base running edge + best defense.
TOR o3.5+100
0.5u
See notes on side & total
Doug Ziefel
Doug Ziefel
Last 30d: 403-339-10 (+44.4u)
Over 7.5-115
0.5u
C.Rodon o1.5 BB+107
0.47u
Matt DiLeo
Matt DiLeo
Last 30d: 56-38-0 (+12.5u)
V.Guerrero o1.5 Hits + Runs + RBIs (Live)-120
0.83u
Bet pregame posted to X
Ryan Minion
Ryan Minion
Last 30d: 238-251-8 (+0.4u)
NYY -150
$3.00
V.Guerrero o1.5 Total Bases-105
$1.00
G.Stanton o1.5 Total Bases+130
$1.00
Over 7.5-125
$1.00
Grant Neiffer
Grant Neiffer
Last 30d: 16-66-1 (-4.8u)
V.Guerrero o0.5 HR+500
1.25u
Sandy Plashkes
Sandy Plashkes
Last 30d: 109-117-4 (+5.2u)
Over 7.5-114
1u
The Degenerates
The Degenerates
Last 30d: 72-70-1 (-5.2u)
TOR +140 (Live)
1u
Kyle Murray
Kyle Murray
Last 30d: 130-143-6 (+1.5u)
Over 7.5-120
1u
Player Prop Savant
Player Prop Savant
Last 30d: 77-79-0 (-9.2u)
C.Rodon u4.5 Ks+115
1.15u
Under 17.5 (Live)-130
1u
Colby Marchio
Colby Marchio
Last 30d: 13-6-0 (+7.9u)
TOR o1.5 Team Total (F5)-110
1.14u
VegasIsMyBitch
VegasIsMyBitch
Last 30d: 0-0-0 (+0.0u)
NYY -1 (Live)-123
0.41u
Allan Lem
Allan Lem
Last 30d: 50-38-0 (+1.8u)
S.Bieber u5.5 Ks-112
0.5u
Projecting closer to 5
Andrew O’Connor-Watts
Andrew O’Connor-Watts
Last 30d: 94-84-5 (+15.1u)
TOR +139
0.5u
BIEBER vs Rodon .5u to +125
Over 8-105
0.5u
Bet to -120
Payoff Pitch Podcast
Payoff Pitch Podcast
Last 30d: 37-74-6 (-2.2u)
TOR +140
1u
@Zerillo https://myaction.app/EY06LchehXb
Over 7.5-120
0.83u
@Zerillo https://myaction.app/EY06LchehXb
💰🦡 Jake
💰🦡 Jake
Last 30d: 84-100-1 (+17.9u)
TOR u3.5-115
1.15u
Scott Rickenbach
Scott Rickenbach
Last 30d: 96-87-2 (-1.1u)
V.Guerrero o1.5 Total Bases-105
0.95u
NYY -161
0.62u
A.Judge o0.5 Runs Scored-152
0.66u
New Owner
New Owner
Last 30d: 0-0-0 (+0.0u)
S.Bieber o7.5 Ks (Live)+325
0.25u
S.Bieber o6.5 Ks (Live)+165
0.5u
S.Bieber o5.5 Ks (Live)+105
1u
Lines at Lunch
Lines at Lunch
Last 30d: 0-0-0 (+0.0u)
C.Rodon o1.5 BB+104
0.96u
C.Rodon o1.5 BB+104
0.96u
V.Guerrero o1.5 Hits + Runs + RBIs-125
1u
Over 7.5-114
1u

Blue Jays vs. Yankees Previews & Analysis

  • Blue Jays vs Yankees: ALDS Game 3 Best Bet article feature image

    Blue Jays vs Yankees: ALDS Game 3 Best Bet

    Kenny Ducey•
    Oct 7, 2025 UTC
  • 2 Data-Driven HR Picks (43-1 Parlay) article feature image

    2 Data-Driven HR Picks (43-1 Parlay)

    Leo Tesler•
    Oct 7, 2025 UTC
  • 3 MLB Playoff Player Props for Tuesday article feature image

    3 MLB Playoff Player Props for Tuesday

    Alex Hinton•
    Oct 7, 2025 UTC
  • Zerillo's Opening Pitch for Tuesday article feature image

    Zerillo's Opening Pitch for Tuesday

    Sean Zerillo•
    Oct 7, 2025 UTC
See more MLB Coverage Right Arrow

Prop Odds Comparison

Right Arrow
Right Arrow

Loading props…

Line Movement Tracker

Right Arrow
Right Arrow

Blue Jays vs. Yankees Public Betting Percentages

Away Logo

Blue Jays

Public

Home Logo

Yankees

47%

Bets%

53%

Money%

MLB Public Betting Right Arrow

Betting Trends

  • Yankees are 3-2 in their last 5 games.
  • Yankees are 3-2 in their last 5 games against the spread
  • Yankees are 40-41 in their road games against the spread
  • The totals have gone OVER in 5 of Yankees' last 5 games
  • The totals have gone OVER in 42 of Yankees' 80 last games at home

Matchup History

Against the Spread (ATS) History

overallhomeawayfavoriteunderdog
Yankees		81-8041-3940-4164-6617-14
Blue Jays		76-8639-4237-4440-4534-39

Over/Under History

overallhome o/uaway o/ufavorite o/uunderdog o/u
Yankees		76-80-542-36-234-44-358-68-418-12-1
Blue Jays		81-77-440-39-241-38-245-37-334-38-1

Straight-Up (ML) History

overallhomeawayfavoriteunderdog
Yankees		2-346-3447-3477-5316-15
Blue Jays		79-8342-3937-4445-4031-42

Last 5 Matchups

dateopponentscorespreadover/undermoneyline
Oct 5th@TORL 7-13-1.5 LO 7.5TOR -155
Oct 4th@TORL 1-10-1.5 LO 8.5TOR -102
Oct 3rdBOSW 4-0-1.5 WU 7.5NYY -151
Oct 1stBOSW 4-3-1.5 LU 7.5NYY -202
Sep 30thBOSL 1-3-1.5 LU 6.5BOS -138

Blue Jays vs. Yankees Injury Updates

Blue Jays Injuries

  • Jose Berrios
    SP

    Berrios is out with elbow

    Out

  • Anthony Santander
    RF

    Santander is out with shoulder

    Out

  • Bowden Francis
    SP

    Francis is out with shoulder

    Out

  • Addison Barger
    RF

    Addison Barger (elbow) scratched Sunday.

    Out

Yankees Injuries

  • Clarke Schmidt
    SP

    Schmidt is out with elbow

    Out

See more MLB Injuries Right Arrow
Blue Jays vs. Yankees Box Score
Blue Jays Player Stats
Projected
PITCHERPCIPKER
Shane Bieber logoRS.Bieber, P542.222
Mason Fluharty logoLM.Fluharty, P190.211
Louis Varland logoRL.Varland, P20122
Braydon Fisher logoRB.Fisher, P130.211
Brendon Little logoLB.Little, P90.201
Yariel Rodriguez logoRY.Rodriguez, P151.100
Tommy Nance logoRT.Nance, P18100
HITTERSH-ABRHRRBI
George Springer logo1G.Springer, DH0-5000
Davis Schneider logo2D.Schneider, LF1-3200
Nathan Lukes logo2N.Lukes, LF0-1000
Vladimir Guerrero logo3V.Guerrero, 1B2-4212
Alejandro Kirk logo4A.Kirk, C0-4000
Daulton Varsho logo5D.Varsho, CF1-4100
Ernie Clement logo6E.Clement, 3B4-4101
Ernie Clement logo6E.Clement, 2B4-4101
Anthony Santander logo7A.Santander, RF1-4002
Isiah Kiner-Falefa logo8I.Kiner-Falefa, 2B0-1000
Addison Barger logo8A.Barger, PH0-3000
Addison Barger logo8A.Barger, 3B0-3000
Andres Gimenez logo9A.Gimenez, SS0-3000
Yankees Player Stats
Projected
PITCHERPCIPKER
Carlos Rodon logoLC.Rodon, P672.126
Fernando Cruz logoRF.Cruz, P191.130
Camilo Doval logoRC.Doval, P13110
Tim Hill logoLT.Hill, P161.110
Devin Williams logoRD.Williams, P261.120
David Bednar logoRD.Bednar, P211.220
HITTERSH-ABRHRRBI
Trent Grisham logo1T.Grisham, CF1-4200
Aaron Judge logo2A.Judge, RF3-4314
Cody Bellinger logo3C.Bellinger, LF2-4100
Ben Rice logo4B.Rice, 1B0-3001
Jose Caballero logo4J.Caballero, 3B1-1000
Giancarlo Stanton logo5G.Stanton, DH1-4002
Jazz Chisholm logo6J.Chisholm, 2B1-3111
Ryan McMahon logo7R.McMahon, 3B0-1000
Amed Rosario logo7A.Rosario, PH1-2100
Amed Rosario logo7A.Rosario, 3B1-2100
Paul Goldschmidt logo7P.Goldschmidt, 1B0-1000
Anthony Volpe logo8A.Volpe, SS0-4000
Austin Wells logo9A.Wells, C2-4101

Blue Jays vs. Yankees Odds Comparison

Right Arrow

Could not load odds

See more MLB Odds Right Arrow

Blue Jays at Yankees Team Totals

MatchupOverUnder
Blue Jays
3-1
N/A
N/A
Yankees
1-3
N/A
N/A