HomeRight ArrowMLB

MLB Best Bets Today: Predictions & Picks for Braves vs Marlins, Dodgers vs Padres, More for Tuesday, May 19

MLB Best Bets Today: Predictions & Picks for Braves vs Marlins, Dodgers vs Padres, More for Tuesday, May 19 article feature image
8 min read
Credit:

Los Angeles Dodgers Shohei Ohtani tosses his bat after hitting a three-run home run against the Arizona Diamondbacks in the ninth inning at Chase Field in Phoenix on May 9, 2025. © Rob Schumacher/The Republic / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

We have a full 15-game slate today, starting early with Braves vs Marlins at 4:10 PM at LoanDepot Park on MLB.TV, and closing with Dodgers vs Padres at 9:40 p.m. ET at PetCo Park on MLB.TV.

Our experts have analyzed the matchups and found great options for Tuesday.

Below are 5 expert MLB best bets today.


MLB Best Bets Today

The team logos in the table below represent the matchups our MLB betting staff is targeting from today's slate of games. Click on the team logos for any of the matchups below to navigate to a specific bet discussed in this article.

GameTime (ET)Pick
Atlanta Braves LogoMiami Marlins Logo
4:10 PM
Cincinnati Reds LogoPhiladelphia Phillies Logo
6:40 PM
Toronto Blue Jays LogoNew York Yankees Logo
7:05 PM
Action Logo
7:35 PM
Los Angeles Dodgers LogoSan Diego Padres Logo
9:40 PM
Specific betting recommendations come from the sportsbook offering preferred odds as of writing. Always shop for the best price using our MLB Odds page, which automatically surfaces the best lines for every game.


Ryan Minion's Braves vs Marlins Best Bet

Atlanta Braves Logo
Tuesday, May 19
4:10 PM ET
MLB.TV
Miami Marlins Logo
Braves F5 ML (-140 or Better)
FanDuel Logo

By Ryan Minion

Atlanta lefty Martin Perez is set to take the mound for the visiting Braves, while lefty Braxton Garrett will be on the bump for the Marlins.

Miami’s left-hander only just returned to action this past week after having missed the entire 2025 season, having undergone UCL revision surgery.

In Braxton’s first start coming off the Injured-list, he got rocked, allowing five earned runs across just 1 ⅓ innings. While it’s just a one-game sample size, I am concerned about Garrett in the immediate future, considering the severity of a UCL tear.

For a starting pitcher who has still had a rather significant injury concern, Garrett gets an atrocious matchup on Tuesday afternoon versus a scorching lineup.

At the plate, Atlanta has arguably the most talented lineup in all of baseball, boasting tremendous versatility in the box.

The Braves lead all MLB lineups in batting average, RBI’s, and hits. They also rank third in home runs.

On the other hand, Braves’ left-hander Martin Perez is off to a stellar start to his 2026 campaign, with the 35-year-old veteran having posted a 2.24 ERA to go along with a 0.94 WHIP across his first nine outings.

In 12 collective plate-appearances versus this Marlins’ lineup, Perez has allowed just two hits, and I expect the first-year Brave to dazzle on Tuesday with another impressive start.

While the Marlins have a much-improved lineup this season, featuring several hard-contact hitters and Otto Lopez, who leads MLB in hits, I still think Atlanta has a significant advantage in starting pitching and hitting in this contest.

That said, I feel great backing the Braves on the F5 moneyline, which should be a solid foundation for our SGP ahead of Tuesday's NL East clash.

Pick: Braves F5 ML (-140 or Better)

Check out Minion's full Braves-Marlins preview and SGP here:

Braves-Marlins Preview Image


Grant Neiffer's Reds vs Phillies Home Run Pick Today

Cincinnati Reds Logo
Tuesday, May 19
6:40 PM ET
MLB.TV
Philadelphia Phillies Logo
Alec Bohm Home Run (+1000 or Better)
FanDuel Logo

By Grant Neiffer

The matchup overall is tough, but these odds and the weather more than make up for it.

Chase Burns is a below-average matchup for righty power, but he's due for some pretty heavy regression and grades out as a 30% decrease to righty HRs.

This ballpark is average for righty power, but with wind blowing out to right field and temps in the mid-90s, the ball should be flying.

I have the true odds here around +850, making this a great bet.

Pick: Alec Bohm Home Run (+1000 or Better)

Check out all of Neiffer's home run picks for Dinger Tuesday here:



Matt Trollo's Blue Jays vs Yankees Projection

Toronto Blue Jays Logo
Tuesday, May 19
7:05 PM ET
MLB.TV
New York Yankees Logo
Under 8 (-110 or Better)
FanDuel Logo

By Matt Trollo

The latest Statcast Park Factors (3 yr) have Yankee Stadium as a top-10 run environment (104 Run Factor), after playing more neutrally for several years.

The surprise may be that it plays better for RH power (122 HR Factor) than LH power (114), but that could be deceiving with the frequency with which Judge goes the other way and it a top quarter of the league mark regardless.

With a forecast in the 80s and a near 10 mph wind out towards the left, this is certainly a hitter-friendly environment on Tuesday night.

However, I’m still going to side with the under (currently 9 at DraftKings), and I believe the logic is sound, along with a favorable projection.

We have a pair of starting pitchers who have pitched at an All-Star quality so far, each with estimators averaging below three.

While the Yankee offense is plenty dangerous, they strike out a ton. It doesn’t matter what the weather is if there’s no contact and they’re facing one of the premier power pitchers in the league, one projected to lead the league in strikeouts.

Meanwhile, the Toronto offense has struggled greatly on the road and has been subpar against RHP.

Both defenses are above average, while the Blue Jays are a below-average baserunning team.

Both bullpens have been in the top quarter of the league over the last month, too, but I’d certainly understand if you want to leave the Yankee bullpen out of this with their availability issues and only play a five-inning total.

Pick: Under 8 (-110 or Better)

Read Trollo's full Blue Jays vs Yankees preview here:



Adam Trigger's Minor League Triple-A Pick

Header First Logo

Reno Aces @ Oklahoma City Comets

Tuesday, 7:35 PM ET

By Adam Trigger

Oklahoma City’s lineup is stacked. It’s easily the best at the Triple-A level. I’ll be looking to back that lineup all week.

I particularly think this matchup will be one-sided because Reno doesn’t have much pitching.

While Oklahoma City’s pitching numbers aren’t great on paper, the Dodgers tend to fill up their Triple-A roster with innings-eater type guys, but they get a nice boost with River Ryan returning to action this week.

Additionally, Reno just lost its top player, with Ryan Waldschmit getting called up. Additionally, Carlos Santana was supposed to be in Reno on a rehab assignment this week, but he just reinjured himself.

Suddenly, Reno’s offense looks watered down.

And in the other dugout stands James Tibbs III, Enrique Hernandez, Alex Freeland, Ryan Ward, Jack Suwinski, and several other solid Triple-A guys.

Pick: Oklahoma City Comets ML

Check out all of Trigger's Minor League Triple-A picks here:



Frank Ammirante's Dodgers vs Padres Prediction

Los Angeles Dodgers Logo
Tuesday, May 19
9:40 PM ET
MLB.TV
San Diego Padres Logo
Dodgers ML (-160 or Better)
FanDuel Logo

By Frank Ammirante

I'm cool with laying the juice with the Dodgers on the road.

Not only did they drop the first game and come in having won five of their past six, but they also have a significant edge on the mound with Sheehan over Canning.

Sheehan came into the season with a lot of hype. After a slow start, he's found his groove, and we have to ride with him while he's in a rhythm.

On top of that, Mason Miller went 22 pitches yesterday. That means that there's a reasonable chance that he'll be unavailable tonight. He rarely goes back-to-back games, especially after a 20-plus pitch outing.

That gives the Dodgers the bullpen edge, along with their starting pitching.

Considering these factors, I'll ride with Los Angeles.

Pick: Dodgers ML (-160 or Better)

Check out Ammirante's full Dodgers-Padres preview here:



Author Profile
About the Author

Action Network is a team of seasoned sports betting experts specializing in a broad range of sports, from the NFL and NBA to less mainstream options like cricket and darts. Their staff includes well-known analysts like Sean Koerner and Stuckey, recognized for their accurate predictions and deep sports knowledge. The team is dedicated to delivering expert analysis and daily best bets, ensuring bettors are well-informed across all major sports.

This site contains commercial content. We may be compensated for the links provided on this page. The content on this page is for informational purposes only. Action Network makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the information given or the outcome of any game or event.